T O P

  • By -

RealDoodleYT

Sammy. The Ink Demon literally controls the entire Studio, Alice is knifing and cunning and would probably outsmart a lot of people, and Norman Polk is extremely fast and hits quite heavy. Though Sammy wouldn't go down easy, he'd be far easier than any of the others


thadthawne2

Sammy would be far harder to defeat than The Projectionist if he remembered he could teleport.


Technoton3

Also, he swings quite fast with the axe, and the axe is the third best weapon in the game.


Crafter-the-box1987

(SPOILERS) But he dies from ONE bullet in BATDR


IEatGrenades2

So would you. It's a bullet, from, ya know, A GUN


Crafter-the-box1987

The VESSEL would, but you are correct. However, that doesn’t prove anything.


IEatGrenades2

I guess that's fair, but I feel like the fight is more in Sammy's favor in a melee.


Crafter-the-box1987

And you are correct. After all, the player doesn’t even get to kill him, they only remove the mask.


IEatGrenades2

Yeah, this turned out to be a friendlier chat than I'd expected, to be honest.


Technoton3

Yeah I completely forgot about that.


Slenderman33366613

Very good point


Opposite-Mix-4362

I would think projectionist, in the game, you are able to kill Norman with a Gent pipe, the weekest weapon, wile Sammy is only killed by something he didn't expect, being attacked by his lord, the Ink Demon, in BATIM chapter 2, getting stabbed in the head with an axe by Tom in BATIM chapter 5, and being shot with a Tommy gun by Alison in BATDR chapter 5


JustDawn8

counterpoint, its salice because it takes ~73 hits to kill the projectionist with the pipe and salice mentions that she relies on thick ink to hold herself together so she can't be very resilient


Opposite-Mix-4362

The Ink Demon can't die, Sammy and Twisted Alice are only killed by something thay don't forsee happening,


Opposite-Mix-4362

The projectionist can be killed by a Gent pipe, an Axe, or a Tommy gun, but both the axe and Tommy gun require special knowledge to access, so, how many hits dose it take to kill Sammy, also the projectionist is the weakest because in BATDR he is the only one of the 4 to not truely appear, as he is ONLY his head,


JustDawn8

it takes 15 pipe hits and an axe hit to kill Samuel and while it takes 14 bullets to kill norman it takes 1 in batdr to kill sammy


plushguy1234

I also pretty sure he is jast a dude that covered himself in ink to please the ink demon if I'm wrong pls tell me


Hank_J_Wimbleton_69

I'm pretty sure he still has some kind of enhanced strength or something like that as he knocked out Henry by hitting his head with a dustspan and effortlessly lifted him off the ground with one hand by holding him from his neck


IEatGrenades2

He *is* absolutely shredded though.


Opposite-Mix-4362

And the Ink Demon is semi-imortal


_GayCouchPotato_

Sammy also just gets shot and dies after like not even a minute of screen time in the new game, so, yeah. \[Edit; Grammar\]


Capable-Ad-2151

Sammy. He’s literally your average church preacher armed with an axe.


Slenderman33366613

Very true


Projectionist666

Sammy just need a axe


WickedGamerYT

No he has the tommy gun. It'd actually the Sammy Gun. Sheep sheep sheep, it's time to weep. Rest your head you're gonna be dead. In the morning you won't wake. There's 12 bullet holes in your head.


Projectionist666

Forgot about that


TheLuckOfTheClaws

He's never had the Tommy gun, it belongs to malice. what are you talking about


WickedGamerYT

Who is malice? (I know who you meant its just funny) besides she said she got it from a very special person. Do you ever remember he saying she liked anyone? What about Sammy? It could have been a secret and he gave her the Tommy gun after things went to hell in a handbasket for protection and afterwards they both go so corrupted they don't recognize one another.


TheLuckOfTheClaws

It's a possibilty, but he's never had it in the Cycle. (also, i say Malice just cause it's faster than her full name, and sounds better


WickedGamerYT

Fair enough about the malice thing but is there any time in chapter 1 we see Sammy? We just might enter the front door right as he gives her the Tommy gun


TheLuckOfTheClaws

That does not happen, no. They're actively hostile to each other, and his cult is littered with ' NO ANGELS' graffiti, so why would he give her anything?


Civilizationmaybea

Skibidi toilet 9y/olds on there way to comment “cameraman”


Robinisawesome_001

Oh shit their’ at it again


Slenderman33366613

Noooo


J_Demon

just get susie mad at you and allison just comes up and stabs her in the back


Slenderman33366613

Good point


[deleted]

Projectionist just grab the tommy gun and dead


DaniSenpai69

Alice ik I can fix her


Slenderman33366613

Your sure you can do that


DaniSenpai69

Idk but I can try, worst that happens is I die, I’ll recover after awhile


Slenderman33366613

True


Busy-Income3408

Allison tried so why can’t we


DaniSenpai69

That’s the spirit


Kyriakakis

I would


Slenderman33366613

You would what


Kyriakakis

I would be the easiest to beat


Slenderman33366613

Ok


Appropriate_Ad_9127

Why is bendy even an option?


Slenderman33366613

He just is


Majestic_Chemist_862

Only way to kill him is for him to watch “the end” making his only way to die suicide which wouldnt be you killing him


Slenderman33366613

Yea


RabbidYoshi9

Sammy: skilled with axe You: skilled with pipe gent


Slenderman33366613

Great point


duketehduck

Sammy. He likes to monologue and he seems slim but not weak. And without the axe he is unable to defend himself


Slenderman33366613

Yep


Hank_J_Wimbleton_69

I'm pretty sure he is way stronger thab an average human he knocked out Henry by hitting his head with a dustspan and effortlessly lifted him off the ground with one hand by holding him from his neck


duketehduck

He is still weaker than the others


Hank_J_Wimbleton_69

Aside from Alice yes he is weaker than Projectionist and Bendy


SarcasticallyEvil

If we're talking straight fighting, probably Alice. Sammy has a bit of muscle on him and an axe, the Projectionist hits with the force of a freight train, and the Ink Demon, ya know, the Ink Demon. Alice is just a hot girl with self-esteem issues. Judging by her attempt to murder Henry, all she'll do is charge and flail her arms.


Slenderman33366613

Fantastic reasons


Robinisawesome_001

Yeah but…hose


CondencedMilkYT

Honestly it's completely circumstantial. If it's a completely empty room and one-on-one, probably Alice. Anywhere else though would drastically change things...


Slenderman33366613

Good reasons


[deleted]

[удалено]


Slenderman33366613

Good reasons


blitzothebestboss

alice... throw ink on her "perfect" makeup, she'll freak out, then just beat the everliving fuck out of her while she's distracted


Slenderman33366613

Good reasons


fandom_slut_

Give a mirror to Alice and say she looks horrible. The fight is done


Slenderman33366613

Good point


Graydogreddit

projector man because you can kill him with a stick (probably)


WilburThornwoods

Myself.


Slenderman33366613

Ok


DevilPixelation

Either Sammy or Alice.


Slenderman33366613

Good answer


DexterTheRando

Sammy. He won’t go down easily without a weapon, but if you have a weapon, it’s game over for Sammy once you go for the head. Alice Angel is almost the same, as she died pretty easily after Allison gave her the Julius Caesar treatment, but her smartness makes her slightly harder to kill than Sammy. The Projectionist is a tough motherfucker that cannot go down easily unless you have some firepower. And you can forget about the Ink Demon. He’s literally impenetrable.


Slenderman33366613

All good points


Robinisawesome_001

But what if you have a hose?


Paper_Clipps

Obviously not the Ink demon In an ongoing fight that can last days via intel and strength combined, Id say projectionist. Sammy can go through walls and Alice is shown to be pretty intelligent. The projectionist, while strong and supposedly decently smart, usually only patrols a set territory, this linear pattern would allow for easy way to outsmart him. Im a purely 1 on 1 fight with just physical combat, Im just going to say Alice because without a weapon we dont really know how capable she is in a fight. In the event of having a weapon, likely the projectionist or Sammy, though Id probably die in that scenario.


Slenderman33366613

Very good reasons


Resident_Toe501

Sammy’s died three times canonically (4 if you count Sammy searcher but idk if that’s canon), projectionist has died at least once canonically (first death in chapter 3 isn’t required) Alice has died twice canonically and idk about the ink demo n but the issue is, the projectionist only got killed bc of the ink demon, and alice only died because of a surprise attack, so sammy's probably the best bet


Slenderman33366613

Fantastic reasons


UltratagPro

Norman takes like 30 hits with a pipe Sammy takes a few pipe hits and then an axe hit. Ink demon is literally unkillable Alice dies with one knife stab This does not take into account their intelligence, in that case probably sammy.


Slenderman33366613

Great reasons


Spycraft08

Sammy, you can just convince him that bendy will set him free if he lets you kill him


Slenderman33366613

Yep


Ghostpaw_octoling

I'm going with sammy because one:He can fight and is fairly good at certain tasks, but can easily be overpowered two: I kinda just want to beat the absolute shit out of him


Slenderman33366613

Fantastic reasons


Lfanberg

Technically Sammy or Projectionist but look at Bendy’s arms


Slenderman33366613

Yea


WickedGamerYT

Alice angel would be the easiest. You call her ugly and she spirals into crippling depression


Busy-Income3408

True but the crippling depression would cause her to get a fucking gun and shoot you twenty seven times /lh


Slenderman33366613

Very good point


4_dozen_eggs

Alice. She only relies on weapons. If she doesn't have one she's done for. Other 3 can fight even without weapons.


Slenderman33366613

Good point


JOSEPH_JOESTAR_BRUH

Alice


AcanthocephalaFew416

alice... if she doesnt have a gun again


Slenderman33366613

Fare point


WickedGamerYT

Fare?


Slenderman33366613

Yes


Bruz_the_milkman

I think it's "fair" not fare


HeffleyA

Sammy, is there realistically any other option?


Slenderman33366613

Some people said Alice


MonkeysCanBeGamers

Alice because she is woman.


Slenderman33366613

Great point


Tincard9757

Irl or in game


Tincard9757

If in irl all of them just spray them with a hose


Busy-Income3408

LMAO FR THO 😭😭😭 wash that damn ink away


Tincard9757

🗿


Slenderman33366613

Irl


Chriscomix123

I found a glitch so I can easily beat the projectionist


Slenderman33366613

How


Chriscomix123

If you lure him to the stairs you can kill the projectionist with the pipe


Slenderman33366613

Ok


Suspicious-Bar1083

Sammy because he’s the weakest I think and he might be the easiest to trick


Slenderman33366613

He probably is the easiest to trick


Adventurous-Drink-38

Ink demon. Funny mask man to haurd :(


Robinisawesome_001

WHAT THE FUCK


Adventurous-Drink-38

He say sheep and I go weeeeee


Robinisawesome_001

Wtf


Princessbitch4

Sammy


LittleHamNerd

The projectionist. I killed him with no gun. I just glitched him int he stairs and then hit him a few times


Slenderman33366613

Easy elimination


Theyoutubefan

It took way more hits to kill Sammy then Norman and Alice is too smart and the ink demon invincible


Slenderman33366613

Great points


JustDawn8

counter argument, you fight sammy with the pipe which take 14 hits to destroy his mask at which point he spirals and without the cutscene you probably could get him from behind. it takes ~73 hits to kill norman with the pipe


Theyoutubefan

Ok sorry I swear I thought I took more to kill Sammy


JustDawn8

some people get the axe to kill norman which does it in ~10 hits so that might be what you were thinking of


Theyoutubefan

Probably


JustDawn8

salice, while shes great from afar she doesn't seem like she would be very strong in meele


Slenderman33366613

Great points


BryceTotalDrama

cameraman


Robinisawesome_001

Kys


TheLuckOfTheClaws

Sammy. He's already died, what, three or four times? He's literally just some dude. Alice has a gun, it took the ink demon himself to kill the projectionist, and the ink demon is canonically incapable of dying.


Slenderman33366613

Great reasons


towoo_are

None of them


Slenderman33366613

You don’t think you can beat any of them


redx32735

The cardboard cutout


Slenderman33366613

Sammy?


redx32735

Yes and the cardboard cutouts around the place


Slenderman33366613

Ok


JodGaming

Sammy’s the only one who dies like twice already so probably him. Plus he died again after fighting for like 5 seconds so clearly he’s pretty weak


Slenderman33366613

Good reasons


Zoeyau9

Sammy but he has an axe and a tommy gun.


JustAProjector0029

Sammy never had the Tommy gun though? If you're refering to Alice's voiceline in BATIM, the gun belongs to "someone special," refering to herself as she has it BATDR.


Zoeyau9

I remember watching a YouTube video and Sammy had a tommy gun


JustAProjector0029

I think it was a fan animation? I'm not sure, i'd need to see it myself, but sounds a bit like a fan anim.


Traditional-Buy7705

sammy!


Funtime_freddy164

I choose door number one!


Slenderman33366613

Fantastic choice


of-course-not-kitty

Bendy definitely not. Like it's demon who's way more stronger and eventually bigger. If the fight had place at studio then another advantage for him. He knows that place way better. Sammy this guy have gun and axe. There's no way. Possibility of survival is like 92% with weapon. Cameraman has really sharp claws but is really blind and deaf af. He will not hear you and you can easily sneak behind him however without a weapon there's again not much to do. You how small change to finish him from behind according to your fight technice knowledge. Alice is overall harmless. She have great collection of weapons which is big advantage of her. She's damn crazy so there's possibility of getting eyes poked out. However if you hold contest of raw power then you as human have definitely more stamina and determination than half rotten ink monster. After all I would say the easiest to fight would be Alice followed by Projectonist.


Robinisawesome_001

Ngl I’m just waiting for someone to say the ink demon so I can off myself


Slenderman33366613

God damm


Majestic_Chemist_862

Inc demon.his hand would hold hin down well you force feed hima. Tape


Hank_J_Wimbleton_69

Either Alice or Sammy.


Slenderman33366613

Ok


RADIENT-RYNE

3 cause she's a woman


Slenderman33366613

Ok


LemonflavoredIceburg

The projectionist. Just put him at gun point. :P


Slenderman33366613

Good point


JustDawn8

tbh it takes 14 shots to kill norman but Samuel dies from one in batdr


keira-r-j06

Either Projectionist or Sammy


Slenderman33366613

Ok


ianthepokemonmaste

Sammy


Fair-Pay4209

I love you Sammy!


I_wanted_wings

The old ink demon. He looks like I can snap his arms off, from how slim they are. I know he's strong or something, but look at him! He looks like an eaten chicken leg.


Slenderman33366613

Good reasons


Majestic_Chemist_862

Hes made of inc though. There is nothing to snap


I_wanted_wings

Then I use bleach or something.


Majestic_Chemist_862

Thats not really how bleach works


Gamerguy4723

Sammy definitely


The-Projectionist-

Sammy.


[deleted]

Sammy is easy but if I get the Tommy gun, I can kill the projectionist easily


Slenderman33366613

Yes


armorjacob

Alice Angel would be pretty easy due to easily being killed by a sword yet a searcher in chapter 5 survives until hit twice by a sword. Bendy though 100% not he can't be killed at least that's what we find out. Sammy can take multiple hits by a axe and live and is stronger than searchers because searchers usually are one hitter by the axe. The projectionist take 7 hits from the axe then dies which is pretty strong. Which means Alice Angel is the weakest and most kill able. And also she sends others to attack instead of when you don't have a weapon she attacks in chapter 3. Probably means shes a bit scared to fight henry face on without getting to figure out how henry fights


Slenderman33366613

Good reasons


Dick727272

Tbh sammys kinnda just a guy, a skinny one at that. Im confident that if you take away his axe most people could take him. If he did have his axe he could probably hold his own against alot more people.


Slenderman33366613

Good reasons


Sparx-the-doggo

Sammy? To me that man is just a guy with an axe A couple bombs can end him


Slenderman33366613

Good reasons


Majestic_Chemist_862

Either sammy or the projectionist. Bendy is practically only able to die though suicide so hes imposibel to kill and alice has too kucht o work eith


Slenderman33366613

Good reasons


CardgenaX1091

I think I'll have to go with norman


RextheDino6

Simple, Kill the deformed woman with a 12 gauge