I think most modern “upgrades” in appearance and packaging are kind of a waste, but those ice cream boxes sucked. They always make a mess especially if you aren’t fast like trying to scoop for a few people.
Penn State Creamery is legit if you're able to make the drive. Otherwise the best is really Graeters. Technically they are based in Ohio but have stores and sold in Giant Eagles in Western PA
There’s a Penn State Creamery all the way in Bethlehem if you can believe it, right around Lehigh Campus and a few other colleges. They have a Nittany Lion statue on a bench and everything. It’s honestly pretty good ice cream.
Unpopular opinion: Penn state creamery ice cream is overrated and just standard ice cream anymore. I say this after eating it for four years as a student. Plus if you look at the ingredients list, you'll see that it's far from the "homemade high quality" ice cream that it's reputation suggests. Meyer Dairy on South Atherton is much better ice cream in my humble opinion
I live in the area my whole life and never understood the hype over it. It sucks compared to everything else. Even a box of name brand ice cream from the grocery store is better than that. So your opinion is completely valid 😂
Born in Boalsburg, psu alumni, I’ve been saying this for 30 years. I did grad school at another land grant university, and they also made ice cream. It was better than psu, but not as good as Meyer dairy!
I've also gotten it from ice cream trucks near Hershey. If you bring your own cooler to the creamery they will pack it with dry ice to go as far as you want.
Long acres is ok….you wanna talk rich keep going south near Lansdale, Merry Meade ice cream….right from the dairy farm. It’s unreal. You have to try the chocolate marshmallow. You won’t be able to eat another kind after that.
I grew up about 2 miles from Longacres (on the other side of the spring). If someone hasn't been, they need to make a time of it, go with a few close friends, and order the garbage sundae.
The Pumpkin is probably my favorite flavor. No other brand comes close. It tastes like roasted pumpkin and a hint of spice. Not just pumpkin, not just spice. I get a few gallons of different flavors every time we go to the Oley fair. If you're are or like traditional Italian, the Spumoni is amazing.
Check out Frecon Orchards too (best hard ciders on Earth). Those are the places I always go back to visit.
Kreider Farms or Fox Meadows out here by Reading. I used to be a fan of Turkey Hill but they changed peanut butter ripple (my favorite flavor) and made it worse.
I like Weis. They have Carribean meat pies that I can’t find anywhere else and they sell a lot of mixers and simple syrups and their natural peanut butter is the best. So we drive out of our way once a month or so and do a Weis run. I will have to take a cooler and try the ice cream. We usually get Turkey Hill vanilla bean. My husband eats more ice cream than I do. He likes it with chocolate syrup and dry roasted peanuts.
Weis Markets two (48 oz, 1.5 quarts) for $6.00 is quite the bargain for good quality premium ice cream. I won’t hesitate to drop $24 or $30 to stock my freezer whenever I’m low and it goes on sale.
And the box would get completely deconstructed to get every last bit of ice cream.
God help you if it melted. It was running through that box out of a small opening in one of the corners.
I’m near Philly now, so the best local option in the grocery store in Basset’s. It my nostalgic faves are Bittersweet and Teaberry from Maurer’s Dairy in Shamokin.
If you want a fun day trip idea, check out the PA ice cream trail.
Hershey’s Ice Cream (not affiliated with Hershey Foods) and Kreider’s are my family’s favorite. Turkey Hill used to be our go-to but we think the flavor (&quantity) went downhill.
Meyer Dairy in Centre County, Reedsville Creamery in Mifflin County, and Ritchey’s Creamery in Blair County. Any of The Meadow’s (Blair, Huntingdon, Clearfield) are great for custard.
Edit: I do like Hershey’s if you’re looking for something sold state-wide.
Whatever's on sale.
That being said, there are a couple of places locally that serve Longacre's out of Barto. Their chocolate and vanilla are kind of mediocre, but their blended flavors are pretty good.
If I'm ever in State College visiting friends, though, Berkey Creamery (The "Penn State Creamery") is always high on the list of places to visit.
Head down to Turkey Hill for a big, gallon box of ice cream.
[https://i.pinimg.com/originals/bd/29/3f/bd293f3b2ad27c7898c2e5f0a97d4523.jpg](https://i.pinimg.com/originals/bd/29/3f/bd293f3b2ad27c7898c2e5f0a97d4523.jpg)
Thank you for this🥹🥹🥹.. thats my favoritest childhood memory.. mamaw always had ice cream and a can of Hersheys chocolate syrup… bowls of vanilla ice and chocolate syrup while we all watched HeeHaw
Locally, walkable/drive thru: C & C Creamery. In store: Breyers but actual Ice Cream and not “Frozen Dairy Dessert”. Check your labels.
I second Penn State Creamery, if you’re up that way.
It came in a box and was 1/2 a gallon. When they replaced the rectangular boxes with the oval containers, the volume went down to 1 1/2 quarts. Another example of shrinkflation, since is 25% less ice cream and I doubt they reduced the price.
100%. I grew up less than 1/2 mile from our Turkey Hill - that ice cream worked for us!
Sure, it still comes in a box some places, but the tubs seem to have taken over for the most part.
Boxes had more in them. 1/2 gallon vs whatever they are now, which is less. Oval containers are terrible. Unless you pop off the lid in the grocery store , lick it and put it back . Couldn’t do that with the boxes. And they still sell in boxes.
Uncle Dave’s in Yardley is great. Meyer Dairy in State College is great (better than Berkey I’d say). If we’re talking on the shelf at the store, Turkey Hill is fine.
I have a few options; I love the vanilla from Costco. It’s from a dairy in Vermont. Fantastic.
I have the Ninja creami and make my own. Delicious and I line what’s going into my oven cream.
Fox Creamery outside of Lancaster. They have a honey lavender (probably seasonal) that’s absolutely outstanding. They get their cream from the cows on their property.
Oh, Lord, same!
I remember my mom getting two of them, then cutting one in half for my next-younger sister and me (this was well before our youngest sistee was born, so just her and me), so that we each got an equal share.
Then she'd do the same with tbe other one for her and Dad.
Ah, tbe memories...........
I miss that.
Turkey Hill.
I live in SC currently, and was SO happy to see that stores here carry it. I can still get my chocolate PB cup fix! LOL
I was sad to recently discover that teaberry ice cream is a Pennsylvania thing, and apparently you can't get it anywhere else in the country. 🤦🏻♀️
to be honest, weis's creamery has gotten pretty good. for a grocery store off brand, it's really creamy and has a nice variety.
OH I ALMOST FORGOT LEIBY'S! LIKE WHAT KNOBELLS SERVES!
Carman’s Ice Cream in York. It’s so different compared to a lot of the other craft ice cream spots I’ve been to around my way. A lot of the other good ice cream around me is super dairy heavy, which I enjoy, but can only eat a small amount and get milk sick quickly when I go hard. But Carman’s is the exact opposite of that, it’s super light, airy, almost icy like, it’s so fucking banging.
Legit I think it could fully become a national brand, as it’s that unique compared to all the heavy creamers or really any ice cream I’ve had before. Not a ton as far as flavors go, mainly classics, but it’s crazy good stuff. It’s the only ice cream where I could confidently say I could eat a half gallon in one sitting without getting super sick. Now I wouldn’t eat a half g, just saying it’s theoretically possible for myself to do without going into a lactose coma.
Hall’s Dairy in Perry county is my go to, always visited in the summers growing up and packed some gallons of teaberry in the cooler. I’m a bit bummed they closed the shop for the season but I hope I can catch a trailer at one of the fairs.
The Penn State Creamery is also a good option, I was a student there so I’d get a cone of “Peachy Paterno” on occasion. I felt it was a bit over-hyped, but in terms of flavor variety and its significance, it’s worth visiting at least once. There’s so many dairies in PA that we’re started by Penn State students (and heck even Ben and Jerry learned to make ice cream there) so I don’t mind spending an extra Buck to help the program.
To me, it is less the ice cream and more the flavor
There is black raspberry ice cream
Everything else is a distant second to me. (Usually orange creamsicle or peanut butter ripple)
I think most modern “upgrades” in appearance and packaging are kind of a waste, but those ice cream boxes sucked. They always make a mess especially if you aren’t fast like trying to scoop for a few people.
They were the best for birthday parties though. Pull down the sides of the box and slice it up into individual servings!
Ice cream tastes different in a scoop vs a slice. Scooped ice cream is superior.
You dismissing sliced Friendly watermelon rolls and ice cream cake?
You know what? That does rule. Right on top of the cake.
That’s how Grandma used to cut the Neapolitan so everyone got a little of each flavoe
[удалено]
They used to have a banging Cherry Vanilla, but they aren’t selling it anymore
They had a naturals chocolate peanut butter that I still cry about being discontinued ☹️
The Naturals white mint chocolate chip is my fav
Bruh. Yes.
The standard stuff is still pretty good. I get cookies and cream when I’m in an ice cream mood.
Absolutely the way. It has been horrifying reading the ingredient lists on products in the ice cream aisle.
[удалено]
I miss the all Natural coffee and the chocolate chip too.
The new Weis brand ice cream has really come a long way and it's cheaper than turkey hill.
I concur
The cookies and cream is awesome, and it’s free with 100 store points!
Penn State Creamery is legit if you're able to make the drive. Otherwise the best is really Graeters. Technically they are based in Ohio but have stores and sold in Giant Eagles in Western PA
There’s a Penn State Creamery all the way in Bethlehem if you can believe it, right around Lehigh Campus and a few other colleges. They have a Nittany Lion statue on a bench and everything. It’s honestly pretty good ice cream.
that ice cream is super expensive! I paid over $13 for a pint one time!
Yea I imagine they make bank during graduations/parents weekend, etc.
In Harrisburg, there is a Penn State Creamery shop, so if you are in the mid-state, you can also try there
Unpopular opinion: Penn state creamery ice cream is overrated and just standard ice cream anymore. I say this after eating it for four years as a student. Plus if you look at the ingredients list, you'll see that it's far from the "homemade high quality" ice cream that it's reputation suggests. Meyer Dairy on South Atherton is much better ice cream in my humble opinion
This shouldn't be an unpopular opinion because this is just fact. Creamery Ice cream is great but it is not worth the wait in line or the price.
Plus the cones they give you at Meyer’s are enormous. Good stuff.
Meyer dairy is leagues above Penn state creamery. Penn state creamery isn’t even that much better than Turkey Hill. I say this as a current student.
I live in the area my whole life and never understood the hype over it. It sucks compared to everything else. Even a box of name brand ice cream from the grocery store is better than that. So your opinion is completely valid 😂
Born in Boalsburg, psu alumni, I’ve been saying this for 30 years. I did grad school at another land grant university, and they also made ice cream. It was better than psu, but not as good as Meyer dairy!
Myers could do with a better chocolate ice cream, but otherwise you are correct. Better than the Creamery and you don’t have to pay to park.
I think some local diners (30 min away) diners have it, so it isn't just at the college. But if you are in Blair you also have Ritchey's.
I've also gotten it from ice cream trucks near Hershey. If you bring your own cooler to the creamery they will pack it with dry ice to go as far as you want.
Supermarket: Turkey Hill. Local: Longacre’s Dairy in Barto, PA (Berks Co). THE richest and densest ice cream around!
Long acres is ok….you wanna talk rich keep going south near Lansdale, Merry Meade ice cream….right from the dairy farm. It’s unreal. You have to try the chocolate marshmallow. You won’t be able to eat another kind after that.
Love Merry Meade. Grew up on it. Had a classmate whose family owned and operated it.
I grew up going to Merrymeade. Been a while since I’ve been there
Have you not had the pleasure of Boehringer’s Drive In just outside Adamstown?
I used to be a Boehringers person but I've converted to Fox Meadows from Ephrata
I worked at longacres in high school! Bear paws is my favorite
Fellow berks how do you do
BuxMont with family from Oley & Boyertown here, can confirm Longacres slaps.
I grew up about 2 miles from Longacres (on the other side of the spring). If someone hasn't been, they need to make a time of it, go with a few close friends, and order the garbage sundae. The Pumpkin is probably my favorite flavor. No other brand comes close. It tastes like roasted pumpkin and a hint of spice. Not just pumpkin, not just spice. I get a few gallons of different flavors every time we go to the Oley fair. If you're are or like traditional Italian, the Spumoni is amazing. Check out Frecon Orchards too (best hard ciders on Earth). Those are the places I always go back to visit.
Grew up on Longacre’s ice cream, still stop by for a dish when I’m in the area!
I went to Washington elementary, small world
Solomon's was my go to, but since they closed it's been Longacre's
Ritchey’s out of Martinsburg, PA! Definitely worth a stop if you’re ever nearby!
their peanut butter ripple is so fucking good
Kreider Farms or Fox Meadows out here by Reading. I used to be a fan of Turkey Hill but they changed peanut butter ripple (my favorite flavor) and made it worse.
The peanut butter ripple is no longer ice cream. It’s “frozen dairy dessert.”
That's exactly my thought! It used to be a sweet cream base, too.
Ah hell, Turkey Hill is doing "frozen dairy dessert" now? That's why I stopped buying Breyers.
Weis ice cream is my go-to. Better than turkey hill and cheaper.
I came here to say this. Weis brand ice cream is made in PA from local dairy, and it’s fucking fantastic, especially for the price.
I concur. The peanut butter varieties are amazing.
we *stay* on their teaberry ice cream
I like Weis. They have Carribean meat pies that I can’t find anywhere else and they sell a lot of mixers and simple syrups and their natural peanut butter is the best. So we drive out of our way once a month or so and do a Weis run. I will have to take a cooler and try the ice cream. We usually get Turkey Hill vanilla bean. My husband eats more ice cream than I do. He likes it with chocolate syrup and dry roasted peanuts.
Peanut butter varieties u say
Weis Markets two (48 oz, 1.5 quarts) for $6.00 is quite the bargain for good quality premium ice cream. I won’t hesitate to drop $24 or $30 to stock my freezer whenever I’m low and it goes on sale.
Reedsville Creamery Penn State Creamery There is no better ice cream but you have to live in the area. Or bring dry ice.
Fox Meadows Creamery
Leiby's. I've had it from a Mennonite store.
They have it at crest haven I just got one a few weeks ago.
Yep, I had it from there forever ago. Wasn't sure if they still carried it. Also, Rohrbach's sells it.
Been really enjoying Bassett's a local Philadelphia company lately.
The fattiest buttermilk used in ice cream on the market. So good
I remember three to five ingredients any child could read.
Klein Farms just outside of Easton
Came here to say this. Thier peach is my favorite. My waist is glad I don't live closer.
[удалено]
Yuengling ice cream is incredible but I haven’t seen it in years. Where are you finding it?
[удалено]
I think you mean because of your excellent self-knowledge!
Interesting. I keep DiGiorno pizza in the freezer, because if I don’t and I am hungry on the way home from work, I will drop $30 on pizza.
Don’t forget Hillside Dairy
Mmmm, Yuengling’s famous treats.
Hit up Mannings Ice Cream, it blows those right out of the water for me.
Just bought several flavors from Milkhouse Creamery yesterday. Yum!
My mom works for blue ribbon I eat too much of it
I remember a box with a clown. Was it carnival? Used to get a box to tea berry ice cream. So good when I was a kid
Wies makes a tea berry ice cream if you crave tea berry.
Hersheys
And the box would get completely deconstructed to get every last bit of ice cream. God help you if it melted. It was running through that box out of a small opening in one of the corners.
The corners were always fun... Lol
Always super sticky too!
Manning’s or Merrymead
Came here looking for Merrymead, although I think Freddy Hill is better. Is Mannings in the area of those two?
Manning's
I’m near Philly now, so the best local option in the grocery store in Basset’s. It my nostalgic faves are Bittersweet and Teaberry from Maurer’s Dairy in Shamokin. If you want a fun day trip idea, check out the PA ice cream trail.
Meadows
I remember when Breyer’s came in a box and was made in Philly.
Valewood farms in Loretto
Hershey’s Ice Cream (not affiliated with Hershey Foods) and Kreider’s are my family’s favorite. Turkey Hill used to be our go-to but we think the flavor (&quantity) went downhill.
Hershey's and Leiby's are the best. Weis markets brand ranks pretty high too.
Wait, hersheys ice cream is not the same company as the chocolate???
And it was a full half gallon.
Supermarket is Turkey Hill, but I am close to Eder's Ice Cream in Montoursville and that is really good.
What your favorite Eder’s flavor?
RIP Hagans and their cow chow 😢
Tanner Bros.
Turkey Hill’s mint chocolate chip. Could eat only that flavor for the rest of my life and be content
I like to hit up Perrydell Farm and Dairy for different fun flavors for my father. They do a flavor of the month as well as a ton of others standard.
I will never forget the one summer that Turkey Hill had Mexican fried ice cream flavor. It tasted like Jesus made it. I miss it so much
Carmen’s or Perrydell
Handels for me.
YES!
Meyer Dairy in Centre County, Reedsville Creamery in Mifflin County, and Ritchey’s Creamery in Blair County. Any of The Meadow’s (Blair, Huntingdon, Clearfield) are great for custard. Edit: I do like Hershey’s if you’re looking for something sold state-wide.
Turkey hill black cherry
Whatever's on sale. That being said, there are a couple of places locally that serve Longacre's out of Barto. Their chocolate and vanilla are kind of mediocre, but their blended flavors are pretty good. If I'm ever in State College visiting friends, though, Berkey Creamery (The "Penn State Creamery") is always high on the list of places to visit.
When you’re in State College, go to Meyer’s Dairy!
Head down to Turkey Hill for a big, gallon box of ice cream. [https://i.pinimg.com/originals/bd/29/3f/bd293f3b2ad27c7898c2e5f0a97d4523.jpg](https://i.pinimg.com/originals/bd/29/3f/bd293f3b2ad27c7898c2e5f0a97d4523.jpg)
Yuengling or Turkey Hill at the supermarket, but Heisler's if I'm going out to eat it on-site. The twin mini-golf courses rock pretty hard, too.
Kerbers dairy makes excellent ice cream. They learned at Penn State and improved on the formulas. Really great.
Tanner bros over near Warminster/Ivyland. the small is the size of my head.
My grandfather would cut it with a knife
Hillside is my go to but Blue Ribbon and Mannings is also quite good. Curly Creme if you really want soft serve in the summer aswell
Hillside Farms in Shavertown. Also, my favorite chocolate milk.
Hagan in the southwest corner.
For supermarket, Turkey Hill natural line. Local dairy, Perrydell Dairy - York county.
Turkey Hill Cookiees n cream is what I put all other ice creams to the test against. Weis is also good especially for the price lately.
Blue bunny is the best I can get at the supermarket
Thank you for this🥹🥹🥹.. thats my favoritest childhood memory.. mamaw always had ice cream and a can of Hersheys chocolate syrup… bowls of vanilla ice and chocolate syrup while we all watched HeeHaw
Before the last generation sold out, Nelson’s.
Ow Wow Cow https://www.owowcow.com/
Ritcheys. I never heard of them until I moved to the 814. Very creamy. And Ripleah's Creamery. That young lady is brilliant.
Not Meyer Dairy. Tastes like chemicals. Turkey hill natural is where it's at.
Locally, walkable/drive thru: C & C Creamery. In store: Breyers but actual Ice Cream and not “Frozen Dairy Dessert”. Check your labels. I second Penn State Creamery, if you’re up that way.
Oh yes I do
Anywhere I can get soft serve.
[La Michoacana](https://maps.app.goo.gl/6amdwcQJLqNZL5mdA)
Yeah, Turkey Hill is my go to also.
Dolly Madison
Turkey hill chocolate peanut butter cup.
Bassetts. Yuengling is a very close second.
It came in a box and was 1/2 a gallon. When they replaced the rectangular boxes with the oval containers, the volume went down to 1 1/2 quarts. Another example of shrinkflation, since is 25% less ice cream and I doubt they reduced the price.
Is Toft's not still in a box?
Penn State Creamery
Turkey Hill. But current favorite is Tillamook Dark Chocolate Cookies & Cream.
Gibbles potato chips.
Nibble with Gibbles!
100%. I grew up less than 1/2 mile from our Turkey Hill - that ice cream worked for us! Sure, it still comes in a box some places, but the tubs seem to have taken over for the most part.
Tanner's (Tanner Farms) ice cream and also pies in the fall
I don't think I've had ice cream since I moved to Philly 3 years ago. I don't know why 😥
Bc we eat Ritas now lol
Breyers fudge swirl
Yes, and I also remember the metal box on our porch that the milk man would use.
Boxes had more in them. 1/2 gallon vs whatever they are now, which is less. Oval containers are terrible. Unless you pop off the lid in the grocery store , lick it and put it back . Couldn’t do that with the boxes. And they still sell in boxes.
I miss Big Chief.
Uncle Dave’s in Yardley is great. Meyer Dairy in State College is great (better than Berkey I’d say). If we’re talking on the shelf at the store, Turkey Hill is fine.
Breyer’s
When I was a kid growing up in Pennsylvania, Weis ice cream used to be called circus… Is it still called that?
Tilamook
Longacres given the opportunity. Otherwise, turkey hill.
Bryers or Perry's
Or when they cut the box away and sliced you the ice cream like a piece of cake 😁
If you want to get really old school you can get some Philly style ice cream from bassets…..no egg yolks like the French stuff.
I actually love Weis brand Ice cream. Banana Split, yummy
Hersheys, or Meyers Dairy
I have a few options; I love the vanilla from Costco. It’s from a dairy in Vermont. Fantastic. I have the Ninja creami and make my own. Delicious and I line what’s going into my oven cream. Fox Creamery outside of Lancaster. They have a honey lavender (probably seasonal) that’s absolutely outstanding. They get their cream from the cows on their property.
Penn Supreme. It was a childhood memory for me. It will always hold a special place in my heart.
If you’re lucky enough to live near a Handels, get their 4 scoop sampler!
Krieder’s Farms especially expresso with chocolate covered coffee beans. Another good one is the peach pie
Gallikers
Goodnoe's, from Newtown (Bucks County) [https://www.goodnoedairy.com/](https://www.goodnoedairy.com/)
Heisler’s or Reedsville creamery.
I really like Windy Knoll and Fox Meadows. So creamy!
So many great local dairies. But if you want to go to a grocery store Weis is a hidden gem
Oh, Lord, same! I remember my mom getting two of them, then cutting one in half for my next-younger sister and me (this was well before our youngest sistee was born, so just her and me), so that we each got an equal share. Then she'd do the same with tbe other one for her and Dad. Ah, tbe memories........... I miss that.
Turkey Hill. I live in SC currently, and was SO happy to see that stores here carry it. I can still get my chocolate PB cup fix! LOL I was sad to recently discover that teaberry ice cream is a Pennsylvania thing, and apparently you can't get it anywhere else in the country. 🤦🏻♀️
Turkey Hill Chocolate Marshmallow
to be honest, weis's creamery has gotten pretty good. for a grocery store off brand, it's really creamy and has a nice variety. OH I ALMOST FORGOT LEIBY'S! LIKE WHAT KNOBELLS SERVES!
You could slice it!
Carman’s Ice Cream in York. It’s so different compared to a lot of the other craft ice cream spots I’ve been to around my way. A lot of the other good ice cream around me is super dairy heavy, which I enjoy, but can only eat a small amount and get milk sick quickly when I go hard. But Carman’s is the exact opposite of that, it’s super light, airy, almost icy like, it’s so fucking banging. Legit I think it could fully become a national brand, as it’s that unique compared to all the heavy creamers or really any ice cream I’ve had before. Not a ton as far as flavors go, mainly classics, but it’s crazy good stuff. It’s the only ice cream where I could confidently say I could eat a half gallon in one sitting without getting super sick. Now I wouldn’t eat a half g, just saying it’s theoretically possible for myself to do without going into a lactose coma.
And all ice cream was “artificially flavored”.
Turkey Hill all day.
The boxes were great. You could unfold them, get a big knife, and have a slice of ice cream. This worked great when serving a lot of people too.
Is anyone old enough to remember Walebe Farms in Collegeville? I loved that place as a kid!!
Just a kid raised on Breyers, Sealtest, and Honey Suckle Farms; not loyal to any brand today, yet Turkey Hill is acceptable.
Hall’s Dairy in Perry county is my go to, always visited in the summers growing up and packed some gallons of teaberry in the cooler. I’m a bit bummed they closed the shop for the season but I hope I can catch a trailer at one of the fairs. The Penn State Creamery is also a good option, I was a student there so I’d get a cone of “Peachy Paterno” on occasion. I felt it was a bit over-hyped, but in terms of flavor variety and its significance, it’s worth visiting at least once. There’s so many dairies in PA that we’re started by Penn State students (and heck even Ben and Jerry learned to make ice cream there) so I don’t mind spending an extra Buck to help the program.
To me, it is less the ice cream and more the flavor There is black raspberry ice cream Everything else is a distant second to me. (Usually orange creamsicle or peanut butter ripple)
Fox Meadow is really good
Turkey Hill isn't ice cream. I lost power for like two days and we looked at the melted Turkey Hill; it still had the scoop mark.
Used to be breyers or turkey hill. Now we make our own and it’s much better, for us. We know what’s in it.
OMG. Hands down, best ice cream - IN THE WORLD - Perrydell Dairy, York, PA. Try the Coffee By The Sea flavor… unbelievable.
Im old enough to remember when it was actually a half-gallon.
If we’re including small local producers, Tubby Robot in Manayunk is great.
Meyer Dairy in State College still sells it in boxes.
Becks ice cream is divine
Bassett's hands down WHYY & Phillies Graham Slam 👌
turkey hill chocolate peanut butter is my fave. I've tried others and always come back to that one. Its so creamy
Turkey Hill, Isleys, or Millie's (specifically if I wanna buy dairy free). I need to know tho if turkey Hill still has moose tracks. Shits fantastic
Hershey’s is what my mom sold in her store and I still buy today.
I love all of Turkey Hill's Vanilla flavors, especially the all natural!♥️
Leiby’s and Turkey Hill
Ritcheys out of Martinsburg,PA
Perrydell in S Central PA is good. Penn State Creamery also