I guess I could see it. I think it’s safe to say it’s Darkstripe though. He’s literally being Tigerstar’s shadow. It also wouldn’t make sense for Runningnose to be looking that evil. He’s not really a fighter let alone a malicious bone in his body. Darkstripe however…
It's not Runningnose. It's unclear who they are right now.
This drove me crazy too, so I literally broke out my copy of Into the Wild and checked the allegiances and none of them matched exactly. However, I then realized the big one with the messed up teeth in the full image is most likely Jaggedtooth (although that would mean they changed his color from orange/grey to brown for some reason and made him join Shadowclan a lot earlier iirc. Tbh it might be Stumpytail but I really don't think it's him because why give him teeth like that and not just show his tail instead?), so that led me to try and look up just who was in Brokenstar's gang (a task much harder than I thought it would be, and one that I was unable to get an actual full confirmed list for), and then check the allegiances of the next few books to see just who else was in Shadowclan at the time while also checking the wikia for other designs that differed from the ones mentioned in the allegiances that might've also matched.
Using this method, and process of elimination, I came with up two possible answers. It's either **Boulder,** or **Cinderfur.**
Boulder would make sense because he was part of Brokenstar's group, is a sort of prominent background character, and his design mostly fits but like with Jaggedtooth it would mean they changed one of his colors ie; his eyes from blue to yellow.
Cinderfur on the other hand is an exact match for the design, scars included, but he's not part of Brokenstar's group and he sticks around in Shadowclan and does nothing important besides being made deputy before unceremoniously dying in the fourth book, so I don't know why they would choose him.
In conclusion my best guess is that the full image shows in order from left to right: **Jaggedtooth** or **Stumpytail, Blackfoot/star, Boulder** or **Cinderfur, and Clawface.**
Full pic had black paws, but I totally forgot the era of the books, that’s on me 😅 My bad
Edit: I’m losing it, the picture I saw didn’t even show paws, so I don’t know wtf I saw
That is very much Darkstripe, you can tell due to his positioning in the over all lineup and colors. The pink is from highlights in the artwork. Runningnose is a light grey and white cat anyways iirc.
Runningnose is gray and white. Maybe it's Clawface?
Was going to suggest Clawface as well. The pink near his eyes could be facial scarring (assuming it's not just part of the shading and highlights.)
Clawface was brown, he’s the one with the big claw scar over his eye to the right
So then that's probably Clawface since the scar is on the right eye and he's brown.
I thought that was the highlight since it’s technically on his cheek. 😭😭😭
Yeah, not to mention it looks like he’s sitting next to Blackstar.
That’s probably Boulder.
Boulder is gray
This guy looks dark grey to me. He's the same color as the teaser image of cinderpelt, who is grey.
That has to be Darkstripe, right?
Can't be Darkstripe, why would Darkstripe have anything to do with Brokenstar or his involvement in the disappearance of WindClan?
Maybe? I thought it might be running nose because of the pink around their eyes and the star
I guess I could see it. I think it’s safe to say it’s Darkstripe though. He’s literally being Tigerstar’s shadow. It also wouldn’t make sense for Runningnose to be looking that evil. He’s not really a fighter let alone a malicious bone in his body. Darkstripe however…
Isn't...isn't this brokenstar...considering he was the cat that drove WindClan out- and he's missing the nose scar.
It could be, but I really don’t like him being so small.
He’s hunched over to look menacing. He’s not small. In fact I think he’s twice the size of the cat next to him if he were to stand up straight.
I think the pink is just some creative coloring highlight. The star is their sharp claws gleaming. This is totally Darkstripe.
Darkstripe isn’t a shadowclan warrior at this point. This is in into the wild.
Oh wow. I don’t know then.
My guess is Boulder
That is a good guess!!!
Boulder is Gray
This guy looks dark grey to me. He's the same color as the teaser image of cinderpelt, who is grey.
I have no idea how that's supposed to be gray.. Plus, he's not Cinderpelt gray, he looks more like Runningnose
Runningnose is light grey and white. Bolder is pure grey
I checked doesnt look like him
i love darkstripe sm
It's not Runningnose. It's unclear who they are right now. This drove me crazy too, so I literally broke out my copy of Into the Wild and checked the allegiances and none of them matched exactly. However, I then realized the big one with the messed up teeth in the full image is most likely Jaggedtooth (although that would mean they changed his color from orange/grey to brown for some reason and made him join Shadowclan a lot earlier iirc. Tbh it might be Stumpytail but I really don't think it's him because why give him teeth like that and not just show his tail instead?), so that led me to try and look up just who was in Brokenstar's gang (a task much harder than I thought it would be, and one that I was unable to get an actual full confirmed list for), and then check the allegiances of the next few books to see just who else was in Shadowclan at the time while also checking the wikia for other designs that differed from the ones mentioned in the allegiances that might've also matched. Using this method, and process of elimination, I came with up two possible answers. It's either **Boulder,** or **Cinderfur.** Boulder would make sense because he was part of Brokenstar's group, is a sort of prominent background character, and his design mostly fits but like with Jaggedtooth it would mean they changed one of his colors ie; his eyes from blue to yellow. Cinderfur on the other hand is an exact match for the design, scars included, but he's not part of Brokenstar's group and he sticks around in Shadowclan and does nothing important besides being made deputy before unceremoniously dying in the fourth book, so I don't know why they would choose him. In conclusion my best guess is that the full image shows in order from left to right: **Jaggedtooth** or **Stumpytail, Blackfoot/star, Boulder** or **Cinderfur, and Clawface.**
Can't be boudler, he's not brown...
new plot twist?
Everyone forgets about TangleBurr!!!! He was one of BrokenStars Foster siblings. My guess is it’s either Clawface or TangleBurr
I’m pretty sure Tangleburr’s a she-cat, and she’s grey and brown
Idk who that is but they look like the personification of >:3
That I believe is Clawface because Runningnose is grey and white. It can’t be Darkstripe because he is dark gray.
I don’t think so. I thought he would be depicted as a grey and white cat in the official medias.
This screams Darkstripe to me - and I think Whitestone is regretting life in the corner
These are shadowclan cats. We have already seen designs for whitestorm and darkstripe. This isn’t them.
Ohh, I see. My bad. I haven’t seen those designs yet.
I think its blackfoot/star, Whitestorm had a scar on his left eyebrow if I remember correctly
Ah, yeah that would make a lot of sense. I should’ve connected the dots when I saw Runningnose. Obv Shadowclan lol
Since when is Blackfoot brown??
I meant blackfoot in the foreground, the white tom
It’s BlackStar I’m pretty sure! Edit: I don’t even know at this point Edit: I’m talking about the white cat to be clear :D
Blackstar wasn't leader yet in into the wild, and is a white cat with black paws
Full pic had black paws, but I totally forgot the era of the books, that’s on me 😅 My bad Edit: I’m losing it, the picture I saw didn’t even show paws, so I don’t know wtf I saw
Could it be BlackFoot? He was under BrokenStar, right?
Blackfoot is the same as blackstar, he's a white cat with black paws! This is a pure black/grey/dark brown cat so it probably isn't him
Were we not talking about the white cat?
No, they're talking about the cat in the middle
I was commenting on them saying WhiteStorm, rereading my comment it does sound like I meant the middle, that’s on me.
Oh, my bad!
No, it’s all right!
Stumpytail?
Yes! That was my guess
Stumpytail has a different eye color
that cats eyes in the pic are clearly green just like stumpytail?
That is very obviously yellow, even the RGB value says so
yellow would be more like blackfoot/star next to him. It could be a very light green or yellow-green. No need to be so hostile?
Runningnose is a white cat Boulder is gray Darkstripe isn't in ShadowClan at this time Stumpytail has green eyes Probably Clawface
He just got his nails done :)
They look like press-ons lol
Maybe its a cat like Stumpytail or Boulder? One of the lesser known Brokenstar followers mayhaps
Stumpytail has green eyes and Boulder is gray
That is very much Darkstripe, you can tell due to his positioning in the over all lineup and colors. The pink is from highlights in the artwork. Runningnose is a light grey and white cat anyways iirc.
It’s impossible as this is the first book + fire and ice
Unless the tabby is Brokenstar, which it probably isn’t.
It’s most likely Clawface. Runningnose is anything but mean
Cuz they all look funky lol
I dont agree but respect your opinion.
I personally hate this art style 😬
Sameee
Like.. I’m really tempted to not support it but I want it for my collection at the same time because Fireboi 😭
Your money and you get to decide! I'm not boycotting it but I'm not gonna buy it haha
Not me getting down voted for not wanting to buy a book LOL
SAME!! 🤣🤣🫶🏻
He finally snapped after every one made fun of his running nose
^[Sokka-Haiku](https://www.reddit.com/r/SokkaHaikuBot/comments/15kyv9r/what_is_a_sokka_haiku/) ^by ^Fhandom: *He finally snapped* *After every one made* *Fun of his running nose* --- ^Remember ^that ^one ^time ^Sokka ^accidentally ^used ^an ^extra ^syllable ^in ^that ^Haiku ^Battle ^in ^Ba ^Sing ^Se? ^That ^was ^a ^Sokka ^Haiku ^and ^you ^just ^made ^one.
Mousefur? Im not sure what the context of the photo is
Shadowclan cats so it cant be mousefur
Ohh alright, thanks
Where did you get this? Is it already out?
Runningnose is a medicine cat and never described as malicious... Clawface and Brokenstar however, both are brown tabbies and very >:3 in the comics
In that frame I’m assuming the possible cats are Blackfoot, Clawface, Tangleburr, and whoever else was in Brokenstar’s posse
💅✨
I believe that’s darkstripe personally
Darkstripe isn't a ShadowClan cat during the period this image takes place in
It could be Stumpytail (Brokenstar’s apprentice), Boulder, or maybe even Nightpelt (Nightstar).
Nightpelt is all-black, Boulder is gray and Stumpytail has green eyes
Doesn’t the cat have green eyes in the picture? At least they look green to me. A yellowish green.
Definitely yellow to me, Plus the RGB value of the color has more red than it does green
Looks more like Firepaw to me
It’s Darkstripe I’m pretty sure, cause I think that’s Whitestorm to the left and tigerclaw/star to the right
It’s Blackstar on the left actually so it can’t be