T O P

  • By -

Ambitious_Tourist668

[Portrayal of Diety](https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/manual/general-handbook/20-activities?lang=eng) Section 20.5.6 This does not sound appropriate. The handbook agrees. Edit to add the section number.


quigonskeptic

I'm always happy to find something in the handbook to criticize the church about, but this section explicitly says that people CAN cosplay as Jesus, but he can't dance!! "God the Father and the Holy Ghost are not to be portrayed in meetings, dramas, or musicals. If the Savior is portrayed, it must be with reverence and dignity. Only men of wholesome personal character should be considered for the part. The person who portrays the Savior should not sing or dance. When speaking, he should use only direct quotations of scriptures spoken by the Savior. At the end of the performance, he should change immediately into regular clothes. The Savior should not be portrayed by children in dramatization except in a Nativity scene."


Jaded_Information105

Sounds like they’re reacting to Jesus Christ Superstar and Godspell lol


Specialist_Trouble22

Yeah one of Bruce McConkie’s “7 DeADlY HerEsIEs” is directly a result of JCS, wouldn’t be surprised at all if this section is also from that. Great musical by the way.


Jaded_Information105

I’ve never seen it because I was told growing up that it was irreverent and such. I loved Godspell back in the day though. Lol


VascodaGamba57

At least Godspell and Jesus Christ Superstar weren’t pretending to be something that they weren’t and they had great music too. Having the SP dress up as Jesus screams “leader worship” to me.


Prestigious-Fan3122

When my son was a ballet student in his teens, the husband of one of his teachers was at the time, or had in the past, performed the role ofJesus in a stage version of Jesus Christ Superstar. Naturally, those irreverent wise guy dance students referred to her as "Mrs. Jesus".🙄 Hey, Brother Doe. Whatcha doing next week? Brother Doe: i'm tryin' out for Jesus. This whole topic is exactly why we do NOT, Sorry THEY do NOT need grown adult men serving in such roles with youth. I get that Jesus loves the little children, but not THAT way! My daughter, 35, converted to LDS about a year and a half ago, and was "called" to work with a primary group. She's on the up and up, and is a certified, working public school teacher, So has been thoroughly background checked. HOWEVER , she hasn't gotten around to doing the LDS church's (or is it just her ward???) Online child abuse prevention training that's allegedly required for those working with youth. I have no concerns about my daughter doing anything inappropriate with a child, I have plenty of concerns that no one is monitoring this, and that they are allowing her to continue without having completedthe training. An organization worth $250 billion ought to be protecting its children and covering its ass better than that!


Opalescent_Moon

The organization isn't following up on it because protecting children isn't a priority. It never has been. If church leaders could shift blame for all abuse onto the parents and victims ("Well, you let little Johnny go to camp and he chose to hang out with El Creepo, so, really, you only have yourselves to blame"), they would. But they know they can't, which is why they offer massive settlements with strict NDAs to victims who have a good case.


Fee_Roo_Lice

I did the youth protection training for the cub scouts, I had a partner that frequently no showed to teach the Webelos. The response from another leader was “just leave the door open”. I was like WTF no! I just had two deep leadership pounded into my head and learned about grooming. Also the kids had no concept of personal boundaries and would walk up to me and talk like two inches from my face. That shit protects me as much as the kids. The church does not enforce what it most likely is required to teach.


Agreeable-Onion-7452

No Jesus tap-dancing Christ. Got it. Jesus fucking Christ it is.


AZEMT

How will Jesus masturbating be kosher with Mormons, but I mess with my little factory and I get chastised...


Agreeable-Onion-7452

Just like Joseph smith could marry and fuck all those women including 14 yr olds but we weren’t allowed to date until 16, same reason we were shamed for masturbation and anything else we did. Rules for thee but not for me.


Ambitious_Tourist668

The way I’m interpreting it is it’s ok if it’s part of a performance. Performance is over, the man immediately changes and cosplay is over. Don’t think walking around hugging youth fits the handbook.


quigonskeptic

I can see that interpretation. I think the organizers of this event are considering the faith walk event (or whatever OP said it was) to be a type of performance


Ambitious_Tourist668

Well and with the SP being the one portraying Jesus, he can easily say it’s ok. As long as he’s only quoting scriptures as he walks around. The dressing up as Jesus does not bother me. The manipulative emotional tactic, targeting youth, and claiming is the spirit is upsetting.


quigonskeptic

Absolutely. I agree it's totally upsetting and inappropriate. I thought the church had made a weak effort to put a stop to these types of emotionally manipulative activities. Looks like it didn't stick.


Morgan-joydestroyer

I really like the idea of Jesus playing castanets as Peter James and John form the rest of the mariachi quartet, but Mormons and their handbook stole this opportunity from me. ![gif](giphy|gMHFX7PEDZEHK) Imagine the fish are maracas and you’ll understand my dream.


quigonskeptic

100% those are totally fish maracas 🪇🪇


Kee900

"Cast a net"?! Brilliant pun!!


MoreLemonJuice

>Only men of wholesome personal character should be considered for the part.  **Uh oh!** I played Cheezes during a musical at the stake center. Many choir members stopped singing when I walked in and I could actually hear many in the congregation gasp! Even the choir director could see the expression from the choir members and she turned around as I walked in. I was told "it was such a special spiritual moment" from several people. When I reached down to "heal" the blind man, he started crying - and so did many people in the audience. I had forgotten about this but I believe that outfit is still in storage somewhere, probably in the basement, which is awesome because now I know who I'm gonna be this Halloween! Ding dong OMG, it's Jesus! Just shut up and gimmie your candy!


dreibel

Interesting- it doesn’t mention comedy.


Ismitje

No fans of "Hamlet 2" and its epic musical number "Rock Me Sexy Jesus?" No? Too bad.


contraddiction3

I bought it for the title. I kept it for the content. I watch it repeatedly because I love it.


GotDuped2

Is this new tho? I swear in the past the church said never to portray Deity ever.


Ambitious_Tourist668

I just checked the old handbook, and it’s the exact same. Which with the church pageants, they would need to say it’s ok, with stipulations.


wunderbraten

The Codex Astartes does not support this action!


Fellow-Traveler_

Heresy flows through idleness.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Spherical-Assembly

It was discouraged (maybe even prohibited) in the old handbook.


quigonskeptic

It's explicitly allowed in the latest handbook! "God the Father and the Holy Ghost are not to be portrayed in meetings, dramas, or musicals. If the Savior is portrayed, it must be with reverence and dignity. Only men of wholesome personal character should be considered for the part. The person who portrays the Savior should not sing or dance. When speaking, he should use only direct quotations of scriptures spoken by the Savior. At the end of the performance, he should change immediately into regular clothes. The Savior should not be portrayed by children in dramatization except in a Nativity scene."


robertone53

I guess after signing the agreement with the Dept. of Justice in which the 1st presidency admitted to willfully being part of the Ensign Peak fraud and paid a $5 million dollar fine, they would not be considered of wholesome personal character.


Prestigious-Fan3122

Who decides if the man is "of wholesome personal character"? Does holding a TR automatically qualify a man? There are clergy of various face who have molested children. Generally speaking, in clergy persons are generally thought to be people of wholesome personal character. I once worked for an interfaith organization whose board chair was a Baptist minister who was groping female employees and other nasty stuff. I'm not LDS, but I am a different Christian faith. My father was agnostic. I complained to him once about the goings on among the pro men on the board of directors, that one in particular, and the others who were sweeping his actions under the rug. My father's response was, "These are men of the cloth!?!?" when I replied he said, "more like men of the dirty old rag to me."


Lord-Sugar09

Talk about wolf behavior while dressed in sheep's clothing. That is all kinds of wrong. How old are the youth?


EllieKong

Camp is 12-18 year olds, OP said they hugged all the youth, so I would assume every age in that range


Lord-Sugar09

With that age range, he should have been dressed as Joseph Smith.


undomesticating

Only slightly better than Bednar restraining a boy and [making him cry.](https://youtu.be/ftp4-kT9VSg?si=BAc_tKFuPC39FhIm)


joshkiba13

I only recently saw that clip and holy shite


CACoastalRealtor

The Pope Benedict of Mormons


Odd_Link_3513

Or when he pulled the whole gotcha moment by telling the missionaries over then lecturing them about wasting time at members homes 😑😑😑😑


MavenBrodie

![gif](giphy|RJAjTowsU0K1a)


notquiteanexmo

Yeah, weird.


kiss-JOY

Creepy and weird on so many levels. Manipulation of the spirit and trying to supercharge emotions. Gross!


sockscollector

He just wanted to wear a dress. /s


captainhaddock

Yeah, doesn’t that count as a drag show?


drj0n3z

The whole jesus cosplay thing is strange to those from mormonism, but lots of christian sects do it all the time. It's just more of the mormons trying to prove their jesus loving cred.


big_bearded_nerd

Are you talking about random people dressing up for some sort of informal lesson, or are you talking about passion plays? Passion plays are common for many Christian denominations, and Mormons have been doing one since I think the 1930s. But I think most Christians would also find dressing up as Jesus with stigmata for your local congregation kind of weird.


Turbulent_Country359

It’s cringey and weird in any religion.


B3gg4r

YEP! Even if it happens in other Christian orgs, it’s still “skibidi AF” as my kids say


flyart

This is my favorite example of jesus cosplay. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iOk3z4VyRbQ](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iOk3z4VyRbQ)


Blazerbgood

Regardless of whether it is allowed by the handbook, this is inappropriate. It is an effort to emotionally manipulate the youth into seeing their SP as deity. It reinforces that leadership is not to be questioned. It is not right.


ProudParticipant

It's giving Pastor Glen vibes.


Fellow-Traveler_

Oh my gourd!!!


TheyLiedConvert1980

I thought this was a big no-no in the big Mormon rule book.


RyanRebalkin

Dressing up as Jesus and hugging all the youth at a stake camp seems pretty unusual and potentially inappropriate. For one, having the Stake President dress up as Jesus with fake crucifixion marks could come off as disrespectful or even sacrilegious to many members of the Church and other Christians. It also feels like it could be emotionally manipulative, encouraging young people to cry and hug someone pretending to be Jesus, which might not be the best approach for their emotional well-being. yes, it's very weird


chewbaccataco

Message to the TBM lurkers who are thinking, "This is fine, you just have a sick mind!" No, your leadership is doing highly inappropriate things. Now, you are probably going to say, "It's no different than getting a hug from Mickey Mouse at Disneyland." Here's the difference. Mickey Mouse isn't in a leadership position in an organization with a confirmed history of covering up sexual abuse and other inappropriate behavior, including the pedophilia of it's revered founder and prophet. There's no pressure from parents to give Mickey a hug. There's no religious connotation, like thinking that somehow hugging this character is tied to your religious standing or salvation, or has some kind of deep meaning. An older man hugging children while dressed as Jesus is very much inappropriate, regardless of the context. Especially one in a leadership position.


Loose-Committee7884

😨😨😨


Green-been77

Um, yea.


kaowser

![gif](giphy|xTiIzJSKB4l7xTouE8|downsized)


Shame8891

![gif](giphy|7JC7bCJJGj44aBwB8p|downsized)


Historical-Mark2365

I have experienced this twice. Once as a youth, age 16, at a Book of Mormon quest. They woke us up in the middle of the night, separated us from our friends/families, loud chaotic sounds, then finally reconnected with my quest family and then Jesus came. He came up to each youth and held their hands and looked deeply into your soul. It was very emotional and became one of the cornerstones of my testimony. Also experienced as an adult at a similar event. I have Jesus a hug and felt peace. Looking back at it it feels very manipulative. Using high emotion to craft a moment. I hope my children don’t have to experience this (they are with their Mormon dad 50% of the time).


hollandaisesawce

I had this too! BoM Trek. Get woken up around 2am to loud and creepy sounds. Herded around until we’re all brought together, look up into the sky to see the stake president cosplaying Jesus in a cable TV van's picker basket. He walks through the crowd so we can feel his crucifixion 'wounds' (bits of silicone glued to his palm). He had to stop multiple times to fix/adjust his horrible wig and fake beard (think closer to dollar store Hagrid than 'Jesus'). Meanwhile we're all being FEASTED on by clouds of mosquitoes. Tinny music is underscoring the whole act, and the music BARELY drowns out the generator in the distance that is powering the spotlight and speakers. We're also blinded by the spotlight as 'Jesus' comes near us. Did I mention mosquitoes? This goes on for about an hour, 'Jesus' then gives us Sermon one the Mount II: Electric Boogaloo. We're all exhausted at this point. They send the girls back to bed. The boys then had to huddle in close to one of the other stake leaders who proceeded to give us a long lecture on the SACRED FLUID in our penis holding bodies and that choking the chicken was basically a mortal sin. He did make sure to mention that spilling SACRED FLUID from a wet dream was permissible... Did I mention mosquitoes? The Jesus cosplay was probably about an hour and the SACRED FLUID talk was another hour, so it's close to 4-4:30am by the time the boys are allowed to go to bed. Did I mention mosquitoes? The next morning, the girls were woken up first and had to prepare the camp and make the boys breakfast because we were kept up late making sure that we weren't going to spill our SACRED FLUID outside of sex with our temple wives (and extra feeding of the mosquitoes). When the boys were woken up, we had to sit at our camp spots and the girls had to bring us our breakfasts. We weren't to lift a finger because we'd been up late hearing about our SACRED FLUID.


nerdfighter2008

Wowwowwowwow


jinglingkeys

Oh I can so jump on this. We had a guy in our ward (total weirdo), dress up like Joseph Smith and came riding up on a horse to our youth potluck at our local pool/park. And everyone just loved it. I haven’t cringed so hard for someone else.


fingerMeThomas

Ugh, this pedo stake president is giving the rest of us a bad name. It's not ***weird*** to be turned on by people touching the piercings that you got over a wild weekend for everyone's sins! Hell, it's just fine if you want to consensually touch adult strangers in the Sure Place through a glory hole. We need to take the stigma out of stigmata. However, it ***is*** wildly inappropriate to abuse your office as stake president, to compel a bunch of kids whom you've dragged out into the woods, to hug you and touch you in your special places


GoJoe1000

Why am I not surprised a Mormon dude would do this. It’s so wrong!


big_bearded_nerd

Oh yeah, that is weird. It also seems to go against Mormon cultural rules and norms as well.


malkin50

Creepy.


Threadstitchn

a friend dressed up as Jesus at a Halloween party he didn't hung anyone thought. The guy that dressed as a centurion did pretend to crucify him. The best part was it wasn't planned, they guys didn't even know each other y


land8844

Like the photo-op of the dude who dressed up as jesus and went to third world countries/poor areas dressed up as jesus to meet all those kids? I always thought that was pretty fucked up, even as a TBM.


Zealousideal-Club985

This literally happened this weekend here in Alberta.


Cheap_Honeydew2986

Lemme guess.. moronis quest


Zealousideal-Club985

It’s not called Moroni’s quest anymore. Just “My Quest”


Cheap_Honeydew2986

Of fuckin course. Tscc and their name changes


Ebowa

For my former born-again days, not at all. Very ordinary. But in LDS circles, hell yes! Edit: this is what happens when you signal to the troops to embrace mainstream evangelicals… you get this result.


unorthodoxreligion

Please tell me this really didn't happen.


aLovesupr3m3

Weird, and gross.


BoringJuiceBox

This would be great to do for someone protesting general conference maybe with a big sign pointing out how antichrist the church really is.. OR as a joke at a Halloween party This situation, yes, very much weird


ExMormonite

![gif](giphy|dWZVqzab8uR4EQSOVg|downsized)


just_the_tax_maam

Was this in Utah?


desertvision

Mormons trying to become Christian.


Holiday_Ingenuity748

TBH, it's not as weird as a guy claiming to actually *see* Jesus out in the forest and starting a religion to get chicks.


NaNaNaNaNatman

Nevermo here: Don’t they hate crosses? Isn’t this in kind of the same vein (buh-dum-tss)?


Negative_Advantage28

It didn't work for Michael Scott either.


Drakeytown

As a nevermo, all I can say is that there is nothing done in TSCC that is not weird.


Bye-sexual-band-n3rd

😳


Tiny_Medium_3466

Growing up I swear this would’ve been seen as sacreligious and so offensive… why is it an entirely different church now???


kissingthecook

I agree. My youth lds experience was far more sacred than it's become. The book of mormon actually has a verse about in the last days the fall of the lds church will be due to the people lifting up their rich to leadership offices in the church, and pride will destroy it. They always skip over these verses. ;)


w-t-fluff

MORmONs play a lot of weird dress-up games. Temple, Trek... hell even Sunday meetings are a weird dress-up event. Worst. Cosplay. LARP. Whatever-you-want-to-call-it. EVER.


Fuzzy_Season1758

I’d go beyond weird yo downright creepy.


Fun_with_Science

Just when you think it can’t get weirder, it gets weirder.


Evening-Oil8363

Super weird, but I also super want to see it play out…


1Searchfortruth

Something js would do


ZombiePrefontaine

Yeah that's crazy. Please tell me you took a picture. Was he wearing a wig?


raging_phoenix_eyes

wtf?! Yeah.


maggiejj

What. The. Hell.


vanceavalon

I don't think it's really any more weird than the Temple ceremonies.


Stuboysrevenge

Cosplay Jesus.... And I thought we were "peculiar" in the 90s. Jesus...


1stwifematerial

It’s strange, but it happens a lot. The Easter pageant, and Moroni’s Quest (Nephite camp) come to mind.


the_last_goonie

THIS is why they tell the youth, NO PHONES.


Thebazilla

Was it moroni's quest?


Pleasant_Drama_7037

So weird. 🤮


GreenWatch24

So weird. Old man hugging a bunch of teens? Yeah.


12wildswans

That’s completely fcked up


Overall-Ad-5680

Totally had this happen at a stake youth camp out


tadpohl1972

There is a picture of a man dressed up as Jesus wandering the Pride parade route hugging people. I think it is totally appropriate in that circumstance


Acceptable_Chance307

Cosplay Jesus loves everyone. I think cosplay Jesus should have a cage match with cosplay Joe Smith to decide once and for all who Mormons really worship.


loveinvein

Not just weird but fucking creepy.


Kee900

Even as a Mormon I would have found that disrespectful. Now as a exmormon, I find blurring the lines between Jesus and clergy problematic, maybe even manipulative. I remember one camp with an "iron rod" activity. There were angels and tempers for participants following rope/string paths while blindfolded. Bishops were not allowed to be tempers, as that could send the wrong message. Ick.


MsCricket67

Yes Extremely


Kolob_Choir_Queen

Okay. Alternative view here. All of it is weird. And it is all so boring! I can see wanting to make an activity less boring and doing something like this. Not saying it is okay, but it is less boring than the usual bla bla bla.


Epiemme

![gif](giphy|UqjLsU9ZsnOHC)


gimmeflowersdude

That is VERY strange behavior.


Early-Economist4832

Regardless of whether or not it's permitted by the handbook - yes, that is weird. I mean, even from a religious perspective ... what's the long game (eternal perspective)? We want you to have a personal relationship with Jesus, so let's pretend I'm Jesus? Seems oddly self-serving. And since it's looking self-serving, now that raises concerns about what other ways (if any) this is self-serving. Yeah, it's weird.


ragnarforge

Lol like that's legit blasphemy


i_had_ice

Cree.pee.


xredhenx

Yes, that is very strange!! Reminds me of when I did trek, and they just randomly started picking off people and saying "your dead now, you can't help pull the cart." I think it came down to about two people pulling each cart when all the kitchen staff dressed in white, like angels, came over the hill to help push the carts. It was supposed to be a very spiritual and emotional moment, but most people were trying not to laugh. Seeing the kitchen staff we came to know over the week, dressed up in basically just their garments, staged as angels, was so funny to me. Coming over the hill to save the day!! Even my TBM mom, who was one of the angels, thought it was ridiculously funny. Idk if that is a stunt they pull at every trek or if it was just our group, but I laugh out loud every time I think about it.


ForeignCow8547

Yes.


Styrene_Addict1965

> While gathering in activities can be a blessing, members should not be made to feel obligated to attend every activity. Activities should not put undue burdens on leaders and members. Interesting.


AR15s-4-jesus

Even as a believer years ago I found this practice to be very ... cringy. Almost to the point of straight up sacrilege. My mom wanted to have a photo of my kids with a Jesus actor and I immediately told her no way, that's wrong.


chromedbooked1

Yes lol I've seen people dressed up as Jesus at concerts and conventions but never doing anything untoward with youth.


bkmarsing

Yes. That's weird AF.


Aveysaur

That’s disturbing


Lilnuggie17

Isn’t that blasphemous?


GeneralKenoBi2228

So, I didn’t check the sub, and I kinda assumed we were talking about like at pride based on the title alone? You know the “free mom/dad/parent/etc hugs” kind of deal? Because gay Jesus giving out hugs (to those who want it!!!) at pride wouldn’t be the worst.


Maubekistan

So, we don’t wear the cross or display the cross because it’s morbid and focuses on His death. But we dress up as Him with mortal wounds and creep on all the youth. Got it. Seems legit.


marisolblue

Wait. Did this happen in your stake?! Not just weird but super weird.


allisNOTwellinZYON

um reeeeeal weird.


Elly_Fant628

Really freaking weird....and disrespectful.


Fantastic_Sample2423

Yes.


shiggles19

Ok, look up 18 Lives and the Book of Mormon on YouTube. I was a missionary during this time and volunteered at this event. I just rewatched it high with my husband since I found it on YouTube. They literally paid an actor to come and portray Jesus in this. And the scene where he is hugging everyone drags on so long and it is just so bizarre watching it back. A stake president is even weirder though… Mormons are just weird.


Flat_Grapefruit_1027

I don't like this and do think it's weird but it's no different than what all the protestant churches do around here


Born-Asparagus-9759

Ew


JG1954

Jesus wept


Chemical-Series8206

This isn’t weird it’s creepy.


Flimsy_Signature_475

As a parent of four adult children but I myself, had all the callings in primary multiple times as well as callings in YW, this is quite disturbing to me!


kissingthecook

Yes. It's weird. I second your observation. Even stake presidents are wrong at times. If I were you, I'd kindly call him out on it in a private letter. In kind words, so there isn't any negative feelings or leadership shunning of your family to follow.


CelebrationNo6010

Not if you get your bishop's permission first.


RealDanielJesse

Gotta love trauma bonding.


Pristine_Platform351

Creepy and weird


bennettmsu

What stake was this? Was it Bozeman MT?