“Frodo Podacter went out from the shire to get rid of a ring, he climbed Mt Doom, but he wasn’t alone - someone else was with him on Mt Doom. There was a struggle and he was thrown into the lava”
This is actually a really spot-on assessment. What better actor to convey as much as possible when only seeing a small glimpse of their physically features.
That would be truly fascinating even if it didn't "work" or if for some reason it turned out horrible. He's such a character and I'm curious what he'd do as Gollum
That's it settled then! Jim Carrey's final and finest role, his unabridged one-man show The Arda Saga, chronicling all events leading up to the beginning of the Fourth Age (in the reckoning of Gondor).
I'm failing. I tried to make a gif of pippin struggling to hold the palantir after he stole it from Gandalf, then it cuts to Ace ventura coming out of the fake rhinos ass.
if a hero could make this for me on my cake day, I'll be forever grateful.
In his early years, I can definitely imagine him playing Pippin or Merry, later it gets a bit harder to replace one of existing charcters as they are pretty perfectly cast.
I mean he could act out boromir perfectly, but doesn’t look like boromir, so I will say faramir. He would play out more interestingly the “is he like a Boromir and try to claim a ring or will he resist” I can really imagine him playing the borderline meneacing figure a ranger who keeps the forcess of darkness at bay, judging if Frode is or isn’t danger, but once he deems him an ally he switches his over and shows them kindness. When berated by Denethor, he would again play it more stoically, knowing that Denethor is failing at his job but respecting his station too much not to obay.
Denethors disdain of Farmir could also make a bit more sense, as he would feel the threat of his son, who apparently is worthier descent of Numenor
Tom Bombadil for sure! The character is super wierd when you think about it. Walking around like hes in a musical when the LOTR is clearly not a musical haha. Jim is the only one that could do that and not seem out of place.
The “Meat’s back on the menu boys” orc
Or
Denethor or Eomer. Just imagine Jim’s overacting in the scene where Faramir’s going to be burned but Denethor is the one who runs away while on fire. Or his scream of pain as Eomer, finding Eowyn on the battlefield. Lmao
His outage from Liar Liar where the lawyer says, "so what's your gameplan, Fletcher..." and he contorts his mouth in a high pitched, "WEE WEE WEE???? WEE-woo...."
Denathor burning with that line 🤣
I wouldnt I would keep him as the mask in a army of darknessesque way. Just send him there as the mask.
"Hold on to your one ring it's time for an overhaul"
Thank you for posting on the sub! Please make sure you are abiding by the rules on the sidebar with this post. If you are looking for a place to post specific things, please make use of the subreddits below:
* Memes - r/lotrmemes
* The War of the Rohirrim - r/TheWarOfTheRohirrim
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/lordoftherings) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Mouth of Sauron
The Talking Ass of Sauron, more likely
That scene at the Black Gate plays a lot differently in my headcanon now, thanks.
Do you have a mint?
Tic-tac sir?
YOU FILTHY RABBLE LET ME … ASS YOU A QUESTION
“Orcs, goblins, cave trolls. Lend me your rears. Aaaahhh-a-ah-a-ah!”
“Excuse me, Ranger of the North, may I *ass* you a question?”
LMFAO!!! So trueeee!!
“Frodo Podacter didn’t jump from Mount Doom **wild head movement** he was murdered”
“Frodo Podacter went out from the shire to get rid of a ring, he climbed Mt Doom, but he wasn’t alone - someone else was with him on Mt Doom. There was a struggle and he was thrown into the lava”
Pardon me! Do you have a breath mint
This is actually a really spot-on assessment. What better actor to convey as much as possible when only seeing a small glimpse of their physically features.
I thought that too! His expressions would be great!! Bombadil or Butterbur would be great as well, but I was thinking Saruman.
😂
“Let the lord of the Black Land come forth! Let justice be done upon him!” 
Gollum
That would be truly fascinating even if it didn't "work" or if for some reason it turned out horrible. He's such a character and I'm curious what he'd do as Gollum
I imagine the pet detective but focused on the ring instead of animals. I can't see smeagol being around much
Wormtongue.
I'm envisioning him saying "la-hooooooo-sa-herrrrrrrr" as Gandalf shows up in front of Theoden for the first time lmao
"His staff... I TOLD YOU to take the wizard's stAAA-aaaff!"
He actually plays a really good serious role. He can play a dark, depressed character well.
So... Denethor?
Yes. Holy shit. This is it. He could play the mad wannabe king so well.
Now imagine Carrey sloppily eating tomatoes, would still be off-putting but at least more funny
Yeah... I can actually see him pulling off Boramir's death scene in the film.
Hold me closer Ed. (Cough cough)
If you watch him in dark crimes he could definitely pull off several characters in LOTR. Dude has serious range.
That's it settled then! Jim Carrey's final and finest role, his unabridged one-man show The Arda Saga, chronicling all events leading up to the beginning of the Fourth Age (in the reckoning of Gondor).
I'd watch it
cast him as both the twin blue wizards. he can depict them as going mad and fleeing to the east
Radagast
100% came here to say this. Only answer
Ace Ventura Wizard Detective
Oooh, that’s an excellent point
I'm failing. I tried to make a gif of pippin struggling to hold the palantir after he stole it from Gandalf, then it cuts to Ace ventura coming out of the fake rhinos ass. if a hero could make this for me on my cake day, I'll be forever grateful.
Tom bombadil
Nah...Jack Black has that locked up.
Jim Carrey would be the Waluigi to Jack Black's Tom Bombadil's Wario
That... makes a weird amount of sense.
Robin Williams would have been perfect.
This is the way!
Without question
I still want to hear him reading those singing lines with Tenacious D fervor
Lotho Sackville-Baggins or Shagrat
Galadriel
Lmaoo I was gonna say the same
Gollum
Grima Wormtongue for sure
Ohh underrated. Someone above said he could play Denethor.
Middle mangagment orc
Meat's...BACK ON THE MENU, BOYS!
A version where he plays every character.
Bill Ferny
**The Goblin King**
Farmer Maggot
GROND
GROND
GROND!
GROND
GROND
GROND.
GROND
GROND
GROND
GROND
GROND
Grond ETA: GROND
Grond!
SPEAK UP MAGGOT, I CAN’T HEAR YOU.
Denethor
Tom Bombadil
Elrond
talking with his ass cheeks. "i was there when the strength of men failed. can I have a mint?!"
lmao that's the scene I wanted to see him in the most but that addition with the buttcheeks is perfect.
Yeah that was my first thought
Tom Bombadil.
Fool of a Took
Glaurung. He could make him really creepy
No idea. He seems like some random guy that went mad from Galadriel's enchantments.
The Balrog.
Would have to be gollum!! He'd be perfect
Gollum
Asking the real questions LOL
Lobelia S-B.
Grima Wormtongue.
Tom Bombadil
Tom Bombadil!!!! Or an Ent..
In his early years, I can definitely imagine him playing Pippin or Merry, later it gets a bit harder to replace one of existing charcters as they are pretty perfectly cast. I mean he could act out boromir perfectly, but doesn’t look like boromir, so I will say faramir. He would play out more interestingly the “is he like a Boromir and try to claim a ring or will he resist” I can really imagine him playing the borderline meneacing figure a ranger who keeps the forcess of darkness at bay, judging if Frode is or isn’t danger, but once he deems him an ally he switches his over and shows them kindness. When berated by Denethor, he would again play it more stoically, knowing that Denethor is failing at his job but respecting his station too much not to obay. Denethors disdain of Farmir could also make a bit more sense, as he would feel the threat of his son, who apparently is worthier descent of Numenor
Gollem or wormtongue
Hear me out, I think he'd make a fantastic Tom Bombadil.
Tom Bombadil for sure! The character is super wierd when you think about it. Walking around like hes in a musical when the LOTR is clearly not a musical haha. Jim is the only one that could do that and not seem out of place.
Him playing both blue wizards is BY FAR the best answer I’ve seen
I wouldn’t
Tom Bombadil
The “Meat’s back on the menu boys” orc Or Denethor or Eomer. Just imagine Jim’s overacting in the scene where Faramir’s going to be burned but Denethor is the one who runs away while on fire. Or his scream of pain as Eomer, finding Eowyn on the battlefield. Lmao
Denethor is an underrated pic
His outage from Liar Liar where the lawyer says, "so what's your gameplan, Fletcher..." and he contorts his mouth in a high pitched, "WEE WEE WEE???? WEE-woo...." Denathor burning with that line 🤣
Tommy B fasho
Tom Bombidil
Tom Bombadillo. Ring-a-ding Dillo.
Gandolf. His wits would make it so funny. Imagine the pen is blue scene translating to you shall not pass.
I am LOL at the thought of Jim Carey showing up in an incredibly disrespectful portrayal of Ghan Buri Ghan.
Galadriel from the Rings of Power. …he’d still do a better job.
I wouldnt I would keep him as the mask in a army of darknessesque way. Just send him there as the mask. "Hold on to your one ring it's time for an overhaul"
Insert Gary Oldman screaming “Everyone!”
Either the gatekeeper at Bree or butterbur.
Frodo: "We are hobbits of the Shire; we wish to stay at the inn. Our business is our own." Gatekeeper: "...Well allllrighty then!"
When the gate gets smashed down it doesn't crush him and he fits perfectly through the peep hole. "Like a glove!"
Treebeard or Tom Bombadil.
The wizard with bird shit all over his head. Only role he could possibly play.
Thank you for posting on the sub! Please make sure you are abiding by the rules on the sidebar with this post. If you are looking for a place to post specific things, please make use of the subreddits below: * Memes - r/lotrmemes * The War of the Rohirrim - r/TheWarOfTheRohirrim *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/lordoftherings) if you have any questions or concerns.*
sauron
Bill the Pony’s talking A$$
Bill the pony
Faenor
Bill the pony
Definitely Gollum.
Tom
All of these answers are actually really good
Tom Bombadil is the correct answer. Because this would mean he wouldn't be in the film at all.
Eru lol
The ring wraiths don’t talk much or have their faces seen, right? He could play one of those.
Sméagol. With the mask as gollum
Aragorn
Morgoth
Gandalf
Tom Bombadil is the only option here
Tom bombadil
I truly enjoy Carrey villainous side the most!
the witch king of angmar
Gimli of course. He's the comic relief.
Tom b
Tom Bombadil. Or does it have to be a character in the films? If so, maybe Elrond.
Honestly, get him absolutely stoned and he’d be a good Tom Bombadil
Let’s give him Bombadil and see what happens
Frodo, when he is being seduced by the ring
A perfect Grima.
Tom.
Tom Bombadil
Tom Bombadil
Denethor
All characters at the same time, because Jim Carrey is a fucking legend! 😂
Lobelia Sackville -Baggins
He could do a pretty mean Gollum honestly.
perhaps tom bombadil
Frodo or pipin :D
Gollum
I’d make him a tall hobbit that’s not really a hobbit. He is sent on a quest to find his real dad (yes I stole this from elf)
Sauron! That would be hilarious but just to add into this I would also cast Danny Devito as every other character
Tom Bombadil
Tom bombadill?
wormtongue
Grima
Imrahil or one of the grey company
He’s one of the BLUE wizards, obviously. Because his robe is BLUE! There’s a reason we don’t talk about the Blue Wizards.
Tom Bombadil
Some mad protector of something. In a castle. With a dragon
tom bobodil
Khamul the easterling "Shiiiire... Baaaaggiiiins"
Galadriel
Tom Bombadill
Gandalf
Whats the bear guy called again?
Elrond, Theres something about the ring ...some thing
Smaug.
Pippin but he’s just regular Jim Carrey
Sauron...
Jim Carrey is the Tom Bombadil of our world
Tom bombadil
Shagrat
Jim Carrey as the voice of... ...Bill the Pony
Grond, but give him a really stupid line when the gate is broken
1000% radagst
Ar-Pharazon.
Gandalf
Bombadil
Tom Bombadillo
An Ent
Grimer Wormtongue most definitely
Either the Goblin King or Gimli. Hed fit right in lol.
All. All characters. Every character is just Jim Carrey.
Ace all day
Tom Bombadil
Golum
Get him nude and crawling on the floor, and he’s Gollum
Tom Bombadil
Bill the Pony
Tom Bombadil?
Radagast or Tom Bombadill
One of those goblins climbing the walls in Moria
Tom Bombadil.
Pippin. Jim Carey unable to stop himself touching stuff would be hilarious.
The orc that shouts: “ Catapults!”