Man I was about to say woodcarving but this is exactly it. Correct me if I’m wrong , but whittling is woodcarving small pieces of wood into a “work of art,” whereas woodcarving is a much broader term where chainsaws can be considered part of the art.
I had a similar story. Turns out my mom’s 4H counselor from when she was a kid was my 7-8 grade environmental science teacher Edmund smith!! He was one of those classic old nature guys, knew his stuff about plants in the area, taught us dandelion petals are edible, how to identify Japanese knotweed (invasive species growing in New England, tastes like the candied apples at Boston market when mixed with sugar), and a bunch of other things. Always loved how some of those OG hippies would pass on their knowledge
I’m glad. I knew it was there, but as it was a good man entrusted with the safety of dozens of kids, and I’ve who did a good job of it, there’s no need. He was simply carving different types of mushrooms on walking sticks, then using them.
His secret hobby is blasting through doors at full speed using the shoulder bash and secretly enjoying the sounds of breaking glass and the WTF reactions from people.
His journaling is sort of a secret. People know he writes in it, but nobody knows exactly what he’s doing. And I doubt anyone knows he draws animals and notable locations. Maybe Hosea, Dutch, and Susan know, but I doubt anyone else does.
I wonder if that has anything to do with (spoiler) >!Dutch thinking Arthur is the rat!< since he’s always gone and when he is around, he’s writing in his journal.
Yeah I think it was a secret, which reminds me in the epilogue John tells Charles "Did you know Arthur kept a journal? I'm something of a writer myself nowadays."
When wildlife photographer Albert Mason [gives Arthur a photograph of the wolves](https://img.atwiki.jp/rdr2jp/attach/1143/2294/Wolves%20Photograph.jpg) Arthur looks really impressed by how it looks so I imagine he got into photography after that
If it’s me playing, then drinking an entire case of beer and whiskey and then going on a train robbery rampage and massacring wary travelers. Then back to camp in time for some guitar and singing around the campfire
Murder. My last playthrough I made Arthur into Dexter Morgan he was a great guy but murdered people on the side. I always made the honorable choices but whenever I got the chance I killed everyone that I saw doing bad or being rude. Even had a ritual to knock them out and take them to a secluded place to do the deed
Eavesdropping? I guess he does that anyway.
How about “Dutchfarming”? This entails planting a concern about what’s going on and then seeing how many times he can harvest the word “plan” from Dutch’s replies?
Nah he's our innocent perfect lil angel outlaw. Anyone who claims he killed them just got in front of his gun at target practice. Not Arthur's fault at all.
My Arthur doesn’t smoke, but he always has a box of matches. He whittles the matches into different “family” members and puts them in the little elixir bottles. He’s got the whole crew in his satchel!
Hello /u/FusroBubba1969, welcome to our subreddit. Due to spam, we require users to have at least 3 day old accounts. Please DO NOT send modmails regarding this. You will be able to post freely after the proper account age.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/reddeadredemption2) if you have any questions or concerns.*
He has them. It's writing and drawing.
Beyond that, a “secret” one
Masturbating
to a picture of me.
Fucking had me dead bro. Just imagining Arthur pulling his pud on his cot 3 in the morning all incognito style and shit.
He's an onanist. He creams his own eclair.
If you’re good at something never do it for free
[удалено]
How can you confirm? Seems he cleaned up his comments or something. Super creepy.
Whittling
Man I was about to say woodcarving but this is exactly it. Correct me if I’m wrong , but whittling is woodcarving small pieces of wood into a “work of art,” whereas woodcarving is a much broader term where chainsaws can be considered part of the art.
Whittling is specifically with knives and blades, cause you “whittle” away the wood
Came here to say the same thing haha. He’d probably make some real nice walking sticks
One of my BSA leaders would whittle a mushroom on top of a walking stick each week we went to summer camp. He was excellent.
I had a similar story. Turns out my mom’s 4H counselor from when she was a kid was my 7-8 grade environmental science teacher Edmund smith!! He was one of those classic old nature guys, knew his stuff about plants in the area, taught us dandelion petals are edible, how to identify Japanese knotweed (invasive species growing in New England, tastes like the candied apples at Boston market when mixed with sugar), and a bunch of other things. Always loved how some of those OG hippies would pass on their knowledge
I think there’s a dirty and inappropriate joke in that statement somewhere but I’m too tired to decode it 🤭
I’m glad. I knew it was there, but as it was a good man entrusted with the safety of dozens of kids, and I’ve who did a good job of it, there’s no need. He was simply carving different types of mushrooms on walking sticks, then using them.
Yeah, I’m actually a supporter and a retired pinewood derby champion. Just a bit too sarcastic though 🤷
Exactly what i was thinking
Me too. Glad to be in good company.
Why would that be a secret though?
His secret hobby is blasting through doors at full speed using the shoulder bash and secretly enjoying the sounds of breaking glass and the WTF reactions from people.
Bursting into a saloon and having everyone stop what they’re doing to look at you
That’s not secret, I do it everytime I go into the post office to pay for my latest massacre.
The Saint Denis barber is going broke replacing all that glass all the time.
That’s so fun to do 😂
Depends on how you play him. Exploring, fishing, hunting, murdering, trolling.
Yeah for my arthur, he's a serial poker player.
Super serial
Same. I just seem to get lucky and clear out the table
It seems like most of the time you can raise the bet and bluff most of them, but every now and then there’s that one ahole….
Flower pressing? Since he collects a lot he doesn't need.
I could see that. Presses then in his journal
His journaling is sort of a secret. People know he writes in it, but nobody knows exactly what he’s doing. And I doubt anyone knows he draws animals and notable locations. Maybe Hosea, Dutch, and Susan know, but I doubt anyone else does.
I wonder if that has anything to do with (spoiler) >!Dutch thinking Arthur is the rat!< since he’s always gone and when he is around, he’s writing in his journal.
Yeah I think it was a secret, which reminds me in the epilogue John tells Charles "Did you know Arthur kept a journal? I'm something of a writer myself nowadays."
Collecting flowers and other plants
He has some pretty intricate leather working tools, so probably some of that.
Pearson has them not Arthur
I was sure I saw some sort of kit hanging in the back of Arthur's wagon. Will have to start another playthrough to check lol.
When wildlife photographer Albert Mason [gives Arthur a photograph of the wolves](https://img.atwiki.jp/rdr2jp/attach/1143/2294/Wolves%20Photograph.jpg) Arthur looks really impressed by how it looks so I imagine he got into photography after that
Crocheting
Baking peach cobblers
Happy Cake Day!!
Thank you partner!
Yes! Maybe he sits with the girls and they have a gossip about the other gang members while they make scarves and darn socks.
Around the time they made it to Shady Belle he took up artesian baking. “Now you sir are a baguette.”
If there was a TV in camp he would be an avid watcher of Pawn Stars and those home video compilation programs
national geographic on repeat
Dancing the can can
Off the side of a riverboat
Hiding things in his “prison wallet”. I’ve seen the things he picks up and keeps and I know it’s not all fitting into that damn satchel 🤔
My Arthur’s secret hobby was fashion and style. My boy always have a pomaded fade, fancy beard, and fancy clothes.
Same!
Yeah, my Arthur was a big fan of that
Eating jelly beans
Practical jokes on Dutch.
He was a virtuoso harmonica player
Writing haikus about whether or not Karen actually has any whiskey hidden under her skirt for him
I would say wooden carvings, or little sculptures
Making dream catchers!
Jacking off
At the camp, straight up Dutchin’ it, and by “it” haha well let’s justr say. My boahhh
To the words right out of my mouth. The mental image alone is pretty amusing. Lmao
I thought this was funny
On god, I don’t know why people are upset at me for being realistic
Some people take things far too seriously
He writes and draws.
Astronomy.
He closes his tent at night to indulge in the forbidden fishussy
Just regularly beating the piss out of Pearson and generally making his life miserable, like Dracula and Renfield
My Arthur likes Pearson. Pearson has a pretty hard and thankless job.
Wood carving.
Wood widdling
Whittling wood
Bird watching and drawing
Knitting, just like kratos
Crochet
His hobby is getting the hell out of camp
I usually make him stare and take pictures of the female gang members' boobs
U... what??
If it’s me playing, then drinking an entire case of beer and whiskey and then going on a train robbery rampage and massacring wary travelers. Then back to camp in time for some guitar and singing around the campfire
Play warhammer with uncle
Murder. My last playthrough I made Arthur into Dexter Morgan he was a great guy but murdered people on the side. I always made the honorable choices but whenever I got the chance I killed everyone that I saw doing bad or being rude. Even had a ritual to knock them out and take them to a secluded place to do the deed
Braiding his horse
Eavesdropping? I guess he does that anyway. How about “Dutchfarming”? This entails planting a concern about what’s going on and then seeing how many times he can harvest the word “plan” from Dutch’s replies?
my arthur is addicted to blackjack
Either cleaning his horse, or, following Micha around talking shit. At least that's what **I** have him doing whenever I'm in camp.
Dicking down the camp ladies
Why does any mention of Arthur having sex get down voted? I think he would be able to bone almost any of the females at camp.
THANK YOU!! Yet wandering the countryside robbing and killing strangers is just fine It's just a game, people. Lighten up a little
people do ANYTHING to make sure Arthur is only praised like he’s a saint. This man was a DEGENERATE MURDERER people!
I wouldn’t say degenerate but uneducated more so
Nah he's our innocent perfect lil angel outlaw. Anyone who claims he killed them just got in front of his gun at target practice. Not Arthur's fault at all.
Exactly, he’d pound that pussy to TAHITI
LMAO!!
Yep, jackhammering Karen & Mary-Beth
You mean karen & mary both
Shagging anything that moves or whittling, definitely whittling
Finding a cure for a certain sickness
Spitting and cussing
He bends spoons like Uri Geller…
Widdleing
Gardening
Fucking mary beth
Crank his hog
My Arthur doesn’t smoke, but he always has a box of matches. He whittles the matches into different “family” members and puts them in the little elixir bottles. He’s got the whole crew in his satchel!
Well we all know Micah's hobby is thinking about doing horrible things to Sadie given how he acted at the end
Figure Skating
Painting and writing novel -Might had published a book or two with Mary Beth
[удалено]
Hello /u/FusroBubba1969, welcome to our subreddit. Due to spam, we require users to have at least 3 day old accounts. Please DO NOT send modmails regarding this. You will be able to post freely after the proper account age. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/reddeadredemption2) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Fapping to Karen
Rolling fatties
Mary Beth
Pogs
Pokémon go
Having sex with hogs
You sir, are a fish
Beating the meat
Banging sadie and mary Beth
nah not sadie, the other women deffientely but neither sadie nor Arthur would try that lmao