T O P

  • By -

cosmicdave86

Maybe they would've beat Turkey for third. Maybe even pulled off a shock upset vs Germany in the semis. But against that Brazil team in the finals? No chance in hell.


Fijure96

Funny enough the semis against Germany was actually one of the best games for Korea at the WC. The refereeing was fine with no controversies, and Germany didn't get a decisive goal until minute 75 - before that Oliver Kahn had an otherworldly save to stop SK from taking the lead. This doesn't take away from the sham that was the Ro16 and quarters tho obviously, but the semifinal genuinely could have gone either way.


eipotttatsch

Germany wasn't a great team back then. They had a few great players, but they vastly overperformed. Kahn and Ballack basically willed Germany into the final. And then they had to play that final without Ballack and they had Kahn get injured in the final.


Noda_Crystal

Too many Leverkusen players in the team that time, that's why they finished second.


[deleted]

Four second places that year for them, must be traumatizing (Runner-up Bundesliga, lost DFB Pokal Final, lost UCL Final (to _that_ Zidane goal), lost World Cup final)


Fijure96

Yeah, it was a mediocre team, and honestly they didn't meet any top tier opposition don't heir way to the final. Saudi Arabia, Ireland, Cameroon, Paraguay, US and Sk. Of those teams it was honestly US that was the best they met, and lord knows that Frings' handball was a penalty.


yungguardiola

As if that US team was better than Ireland. Don't even think there was a single position they were stronger in never mind the whole XI


BigChung0924

yeah that irish team was consistently ranked top 10 in the world for a few years and had some solid players(and obviously one legend in roy keane, but he walked out on the tournament)


saeuta31

True, but you win some you lose some. The US had a handball not called against them the prior game.


U-701

Man that game made me a football fan, and Oliver Kahn my big idol. He was just the best for a 7 year old


[deleted]

Ronaldo Rivaldo Ronaldinho Roberto Carlos Cafu


thefogdog

Kaka, Lucio, Dida, Honestly nobody else stood a chance.


Fapoleon_Boneherpart

Kaka probably got like ten minutes tops of game time.


Banksmans

Dida wasn’t first choice that World Cup it was Marcos


u4004

Rogério Ceni was actually second-choice. According to Marcos, when they trained starters vs reserves his long balls caused tons of trouble for them.


[deleted]

Kleberson


maybe_there_is_hope

Vampeta


Sir_Boldrat

Denilson


Up_The_Mariners

Missing the main man Polga there


ValleyFloydJam

I believe we might have won the WC, if we didn't have to play that awesome side.


[deleted]

Lmfao. All-star line up right there. Pretty much the best national team of all time in history.


Inkmaster-reaper-atl

That would be Brazil 2006


HappyMeerkat

I imagine lots of countries could have won many trophies if you pick and choose certain players from different eras to play countries still of the same era


[deleted]

[удалено]


[deleted]

Sounds like a nightmare for both teams


los_blanco_14

Makelele and veira still better


Ickyhouse

But Kanté would be great for a Viera backup for when he gets his red cards.


[deleted]

Two i’s


shitpumper

Either one does the job of two players in midfield so it would be a bit of a waste and result in the most turgid midfield ever.


revjor

I dunno, I think it could work, Kante is pretty good at advancing the ball in ways Makelele didn't really do. You could do Kante, Makelele, Vieria with Zidane, Platini and Henry above them and probably score plenty of goals.


panopss

Imagine your 2018 WC team with Suker


[deleted]

Portugal with Ronaldo and Figo in 1966 would have won


zeekoes

Imagine the 2010 final with peak Cruyff, Van Basten, Van Hanegem, Bergkamp and add Van Dijk and De Ligt in defense instead of Heitinga and Mathijssen!


mattijn13

Van der Sar, Krol, Koeman, Van Dijk, Rijkaard, Neeskens, Van Hanegem, Gullit, Bergkamp, Van Basten, Cruijff. Van Breukelen, De Boer, Stam, Robben, Seedorf, Davids, Sneijder, Rensenbrink, Haan, Rep, Van Persie, Wilkes and Lenstra on the bench


elgallogrande

You know Cruijff and the old boys would be puking themselves trying to keep up with a 2010 team, right? One of Seedorfs legs has more stamina than all of the 1974 elftal combined. They thought long jogs followed by a smoke were good training lol.


C11PO

I’m guessing we are assuming sports science and match fitness all held constant, but I agree it’s too many of them old timers in the starting 11 and not enough of the 90-00s generation that were amazing too Edit: just realized that Van Nistelrooy isn’t even on the list 😅


WhoEatsRusk

Bigger question is how can you even improve the 2010 Spain team


SAFFATLOL

Convince Messi to play for Spain


C11PO

Really, the only answer lol.


MagmaWhales

Alba at left back


zeekoes

Raul? They desperately needed a striker.


WhoEatsRusk

They had Villa and Torres


Harudera

Doubtful. He was a cancer. It's not a coincidence that Spain went from perennial bottlers to winners as soon as his toxic ass was thrown out.


RaioNoTerasu

Morientes then


msc43

It also helped immensely that Torres from 08-10 was unplayable.


Logseman

Which we got between 2008-2012. No matter how hard managers have worked since the beginning of the past decade to phase out the number 9 to bring more flexible profiles, they simply cannot do without.


KinneySL

With di Stéfano, but that's about it.


ChaosRaiden

Martin Peters - Hurst - Jarrod Bowen I live


AnnieIWillKnow

Where is Mark Noble??


HAWmaro

Lol no one is beating that brazil generation I feel.


L-Freeze

Also if you pick and choose the referees…


los_blanco_14

Its just like Croatia would have won the WC in 98 if modric was there. Its bs


Mr-Stitch

If we had Cruijff in 2010 we probably would've won as well


daveSavesAgain

Why? Coz he would bench Sneijder?


thefogdog

I mean, yes, of course he would have


RadJames

The WC of the year Wes could have won a ballon d’or and equal top scored? Obviously Cruyff was something else but… it’s a strange one to pick.


Nbuuifx14

Anybody who chooses Wesley Sneijder over Cruyff should be arrested immediately for everybody else’s safety.


elgallogrande

You think pack a day Cruijff would last 90 minutes in a modern game? All his talent would've withered away after 20 minutes in the African heat.


thefogdog

If he played today, he'd have the benefit of today's nutrition, sport's science and ultra-professionalism. Comments like this aren't well though-out.


GrizzyLizz

The 2010 WC happened during winter in South Africa


Mr_Miscellaneous

Man, the Spanish and the Italians are about to go nuts in this thread.


Borderedge

Moreno is so hated that he was invited to referee a 7 a side football match in Italy so the crowd could boo and insult him live. Before that he was invited to a Carnival parade for the same reason. Some town in Sicily also named the public toilets after him for 10 years... You have no idea.


BigChung0924

wasn’t he caught trafficking drugs? or was that someone else?


[deleted]

With good reason to be fair, that World Cup was very very dodgy.


nighthawkz_2002

wait till november


stpstrt

Urgh. I have a feeling it’s going to be absolutely fetid.


Sir_Boldrat

No way Qatar would even attempt what South Korea did in 2002 (blatant corruption). SK relied on the perception that they have an ok team and are at home. Plausible deniability. One positive result for Qatar and you know what everyone will be thinking.


neilcmf

I think Qatar will have ''wtf?''-moments more like South Africa in 2010, ie not refereeing corruption necessarily but just things on and off the pitch that makes you go ''what the hell is even going on'' My favs from 2010: Vuvuzelas, all the Jabulani complaints, French NT drama, Suarez handball. SA2010 was a dramatic, chaotic mess from start to finish but damn was it entertaining.


Barry_McCocciner

The goddamn Jabulani... still can't believe they played a WC with a glorified beach ball. That thing was an absolute nightmare for the people trying to kick or save it. It was way too light, insanely easy to make knuckle, and didn't bend like a normal ball if you hit it with spin.


Morganelefay

Meanwhile Van Bronckhorst be like "I don't see a problem here."


Mr_Miscellaneous

SA2010 might just be the worst World Cup in history. I get that this subreddit skews young and that will be their first memory of a world cup but it was dire.


C11PO

It’s because a lot of the traditionally strong national teams were in transition/not fully peaking yet, and Spain were like the infinity gauntlet of a team. Everyone that tried to play them had no answers for them and were dragging matches to unwatchable spectacles hoping for a knockout punch


neilcmf

I was 10 at the time, so I very much admit that most of my appreciation for the 2010 WC tournament is derived purely from childhood nostalgia. Don't be fooled though - Qatar 22 is **already** the worst World Cup and it hasn't even started yet. I'll stand by that purely because The Guardian estimated that over [6 000 workers have died](https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2021/feb/23/revealed-migrant-worker-deaths-qatar-fifa-world-cup-2022) in the construction process, and that's a **conservative** estimate.


Mr_Miscellaneous

It's going to have absolutely no atmosphere whatsoever, the football is going to be turgid and it's going to be December so we'll all be working/studying/pissed off at winter making everything dark at 3/4pm. Going to be grim, I'm in no mood for a "festival of football" in a slave state during December.


BigChung0924

even if they wanted to do the middle east, why not do it somewhere with actual footballing culture?


IMKudaimi123

Suarez handball still pisses me off, Ghana deserved to go through


stpstrt

While SK were a much better team than Qatar back then, they had absolutely no business beating us and the Italians.


L-Freeze

Qatar are Asian champions, they’re not South Africa tier of bad. It’s highly unlikely but not completely out of the cards that they could make it to r16 as they’ve got a pretty weak group anyways


Morganelefay

Pretty weak? They got no glaring weak opposition. I can see them steal one point and that's about it, while whichever team is the one who slips up against them will have an uphill struggle getting out of the group.


down_up__left_right

They won the 2019 AFC Asian Cup so they're probably going to be better than most people think. For reference before hosting the World Cup South Korea got 3rd in the 2000 AFC Asian Cup.


ValleyFloydJam

No idea wasn't, the ref made errors but that happens, it's more those fans couldn't handle losing to that side, so added conspiracy.


[deleted]

[удалено]


ValleyFloydJam

People built them up that's why, they couldn't handle losing to a smaller football nation. They were errors, it's not like the ref made 5 good goals disappear and gave them the winner. Incompetence is always the most likely reason for a mistake, see Masi and nothing gets to that level of fuck up either.


[deleted]

[удалено]


69blazeit69chungus

This guy above you is acting like an Italian striker didn’t get fouled in the box for a clear penalty, only to get sent off for diving


ValleyFloydJam

Cos a ref has never gotten those things wrong before.


ValleyFloydJam

Ah the old someone disagrees so there trolling argument. Well I was saying in the same game and no winners were gifted. Again you act like I'm claiming the ref got it all right, I'm saying the refs fucked up but that it wasn't rigged. Refs make bad calls, South Korea played well in that tournament and got some luck with those decisions too. My reaction is the same to any situation where someone calls a game rigged without real proof. Right not on the concept of disallowed goals, that's false, if the whistle has gone before the shot how is it a real goal, is the ref psychic? Cos Spain's first, the whistle goes as the header happens, yes it's a soft free kick but refs give them in the box all the time and it only becomes a thing if the ball finds the net. And with the second the flag is up before the ball is crossed, a mistake but linos have made worse. With Italy the chance was clearer but that's a bloody tight offside call to land on rigged.


EcosseWolf

With good reason.


BerndDasBrotVollkorn

Rightly so. Most rigged thing I've seen at a World Cup


Dichroic_Mirror

I am neither Spanish nor Italian, but I got so livid whenever I heard South Korean brags about their 4th place finish at 2002.


Acceptable-Bet-982

Brasil would Win 2006, 2010, 2014 if we had Pelé, Rivelino and Garrincha :(


niemody

And now imagine the world Cup 02 with functional VAR system.


Fkappa

Fuck Byron Moreno e Forza Azzurri.


stpstrt

Fuck Byron Moreno and Al-Ghandour


Fkappa

Yeah, of course, fuck Al-Ghandour too, you loser egypto-korean bitch.


shitpumper

Nah they had their stars in Gamal Al-Ghandour and Byron Moreno and that wasn't enough.


BroccoliDistribution

I don’t think Korea needed Son then. They just needed to bride two more refs.


aksmelo4352

Yeah true


TechnoBeats99

This should be a fun thread


Vallado

Turkey came third in the 2002 WC, they definitely would have won it if they had big Çağlar Söyüncü playing with them


Aenjeprekemaluci

Or prime Arda Turan. Lel. Seriously stupid arguments


Malicharo

Midfield of Prime Arda, Nuri, Hamit.


DontJealousMe

I know you jest but I’d rather have Bulent Korkmaz and Alpay. Lol


Malicharo

Giga Çağlar coming in clutch with 17' red card.


AggravatingWar9441

Ma vaffanculo. Arbitro infame per te solo lame, Moreno pezzo di merda. 20 years later we still haven’t forgotten, we will never forget


HeavyGogs

Corrupt officials were the only reason they got as far as they did


[deleted]

You’re being downvoted but there is a very strong claim to support this, if people went back and watched the games you’d see why, very questionable.


Aenjeprekemaluci

Especially the Italy game. No wonder people believe it was rigged for South Korea


Local-Pirate1152

For me the Spain game was more blatant. Goals ruled out when the ball was supposedly out of play when it wasn't even close to being out and the goalkeeper saving penalties when he was about 3 or 4 yards off his line


MediocreLab318

I’d take the claims more seriously if they whistled after the goal. They immediately whistled as the player headed the ball in the first scenario and as the cross was made in the second scenario. Back then so many erroneous calls were made for balls going out/line (even today) and obviously no VAR back then as well. I can understand referees making those wrong calls, and those stand out more when teams like Spain are more favored to win than S. Korea that nobody probably ever heard of back then. (Plus, nobody talks about how the home game advantage playing a big role in their team playing their heart out.) I’m not counting out corruption, but I’m certain so many other games are just as prone to corruption/referee bias claims. Just stands out a lot more when it’s a WC knockout stage vs a European elite team.


Local-Pirate1152

The world cup always has been and always will be corrupt as fuck. From the awarding to the refereeing to sometimes even the qualifying.


Sproeier

Are there people contesting this? Some of their games were ridiculous, not the fault of the players or coach though.


[deleted]

They're being downvoted because the majority of people in here aren't old enough to remember the 2002 world cup. Seriously, go back and watch their games against Spain & Italy. Those two games are the finest examples of match-fixing I have ever seen at the highest levels of football. Absolutely no doubt in my mind.


loser0001

I've never voiced this opinion here before because it goes against the popular narrative, but I did watch the entire Italy match in 2020 when football was called off. I was expecting something shocking. Maybe it had been overhyped, but it seemed like any standard game for that time period. People say the Spain match had worse refereeing though.


shinemire

Definitely suspicious af no question. On the other hand........Spain and Italy should have toyed with Korea with one eye closed the home crowd advantage definitely pushed them.


Local-Pirate1152

Spain did toy with them and had two perfectly good goals ruled out and the Korean goalie was saving penalties 3 or 4 yards off his line. It was a disgraceful refereeing performance.


astral34

They sent off Totti (one of the best itw) for diving (2nd yellow) when it was a clear pen. Fuck Moreno, denied one of the greatest back lines to ever compete of a very good chance for a WC


Billofrights_boris

Yeah we would have qualified for the World Cup if we had Puskas


[deleted]

They shouldn’t have needed Son to win. They already had all the referees in their pocket in that tournament.


[deleted]

Yeah if Son was semis referee than for sure. What referee did against us and Italy was big shame.


[deleted]

[удалено]


Starbuck1992

The referee for Italy's match, Byron Moreno, was later disqualified as a referee for match fixing (unrelated to the world cup), and he was then arrested for smuggling drugs in the US. So yeah, even without looking at the match it's a believable claim


stpstrt

The ref for the Spain match never officiated another game either.


ValleyFloydJam

Then you're a fool, spreading this nonsense about is shameful.


[deleted]

[удалено]


ValleyFloydJam

Yes but you need more proof than ref got it wrong.


ValleyFloydJam

When people don't like decisions and just going for rigged, it's lazy, boring and dangerous. The ref made errors but refs always make errors, they have made worse errors but it doesn't mean they are on the take.


stpstrt

Tell me you didn’t watch WC02 without telling me you didn’t watch WC02


ValleyFloydJam

I did, I just don't spread bs.


stpstrt

You claimed 86 was worse lol. Clear bias, get out of here.


ValleyFloydJam

Not rigged though, a worse decision. How is that bias, show me something worse than a guy jumping with his hand above his head and clearly punching the ball into the net? That decision is an all time piece of cheating and dreadful call.


stpstrt

The same kind of fuckery, multiple times per game for like 3 games in a row, involving the host nation of that particular World Cup. Nah but the hand of god is worse. And that’s not English bias? Give your head a wobble.


stpstrt

Man scroll through the thread and look what the majority of people are posting. But nah, you’ll die on that hill for some strange reason.


JetstreamTheBlueSky

Stop right there, 2002 was 100% rigged


ValleyFloydJam

You can't just spread that be cos the ref got decisions wrong. I've seen many worse calls.


RhydonHerSlowbro

No comments about how absolutely scandalous and filthy South Korea’s run was in that tournament? Paid off officials, disgusting “play” if you can call it that? Why would anyone reference that tournament talking about South Korea in a good light?? Cheated against Italy, cheated against Spain, thankfully destroyed by Germany.


HiMyNameIsSander

I mean, it's Hiddink, South Korea's coach back then. He got interviewed in Seoul and got asked this question. I don't think they'd appreciated it if he told the truth behind their WC run. Plus, his legendary status over there would get revoked. His answer is understandable considering these factors. He knows their WC run was a sham, but why would he bother angering his fans, especially after 20 years. He could've said 'maybe' or 'I don't know' to prevent this from getting more exposure, I guess.


RhydonHerSlowbro

I didn’t mean comments from him, I meant from this comment thread and/or the rest of the world!


nighthawkz_2002

thats like saying, had harry maguire played in 1966 he would've won the world cup for germany


NonZealot

[And if my grandmother had wheels she would have been a bike.](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-RfHC91Ewc)


stpstrt

Son + the refs they paid off.


scrandymurray

If my grandmother had wheels, she would be a bike.


SebLestrange

Maybe with Son refereeing...


HAWmaro

As good as Son is, all 3 of Brazil forwards back then are a level above him. this is not to even begin on the rest of that team.


EarthPutra

Son + 30m USD dirty money might get it done.


stratrookie

Congrats South Korea!


loveandmonsters

Argentina would have won 1990 WC with Messi


Dsalgueiro

If we had Pelé, Garrincha, Ronaldo, Romário, Zico, Ronaldinho, Didi, Tostão... Ok, I can't name them all... I think we would be, at least, Hexa.


irrenhouse

Well they should have called him up then.


DarajaMbili

That’s a lot of pressure for a 10 year old kid.


czz77

ok


tarakian-grunt

It's your fault for not calling him up then.


MixedJiChanandsowhat

Great coach but lots of his recent takes have been ridiculous as hell hahaha. Here he's acting like if fixing hadn't been part of his and Korea success in 2002 World Cup, but recently he was speaking how he felt suspicious about the UEFA fixing games when he was the coach of Chelsea in Champion's League. Ridiculous!


TheDavinci1998

As a referee maybe, cause that was that Korea's strongest position


CheekyKunt68

No shit he’s the greatest ever Asian player to grace the game


HAWmaro

The disrespect to captain tsubasa!


Faabz

What about Misaki, Hyuga, Misugi and Wakabayashi?


HAWmaro

Wakabayashi would be the goat but he's more injury prone than Dembele.


Faabz

But he is there when he matters and we still have Wakashimazu so its all good


Nbuuifx14

Keisuke Honda slander.


WhoEatsRusk

Def top 5 but not the best compared to Cha Bum Kun, Park Ji Sung, Ali Daei, Hidetoshi Nakata


[deleted]

Argentina would have won most world cups if they had Messi. Ohh wait..


Murrayhewittrocks

And Belgium would've won without Prendergast


CaredForEightSeconds

Guus 💙


[deleted]

"would, could, should" are terms that are meaningless in football. Either it happened or not, the rest is just fantasy.


PBJellyChickenTunaSW

Depends if Ireland had Roy Keane in the timeline or not


gaberdop

And the same referees maybe


red_in_iowa

Wasn't he only 10 in '02? I'm not sure how much help he would've been....


pyck-aussie

Fucking hell! That game against Italy was a sham! That was some Italy team and they were robbed


urangminang

I believe England would've win WC 2006 with a full list of superstars in their squad, oh wait...


Malicharo

By that logic Turkey would have also won if they had prime Arda and Nuri in the midfield or whatever. But no they wouldn't, that Brazilian team was stacked as fuck. No team stood a chance.


Soren_Camus1905

Between Son and the refs probably


Believeinyourflyness

My aunt would be my uncle if she had balls between her legs


therealowlman

Had they had VAR would have Korea out in the round of 16. Had to be the worst officiating in WC history.


[deleted]

[удалено]


ValleyFloydJam

Make Rooney 2 years older and Beckham not playing hurt and who knows but that Brazil side had all the pieces.


aksmelo4352

I don't think a 14 year old rooney would have done much


ValleyFloydJam

Silly fuck up fixed.


Hazardzuzu

2002 was also the last time any WC had good refs. It's been a steady decline since.


snoop_chinchilla

>2002 was also the last time any WC had good refs. It's been a steady decline since. Wait WHAT


Chianti96

HUH ?


Thraff1c

Nice meme


Aenjeprekemaluci

2002 is the worst ever tournament regarding referees ever!


ValleyFloydJam

Nope, 86 is still the worse, you will never see a bigger more obvious call missed.


stpstrt

Tell me you didn’t watch the 2002 WC without telling me you didn’t watch the 2002 WC.


FloppedYaYa

And Leicester would have won the Premier League in 1994 with Vardy, Mahrez, Kante and Ranieri