The mighty fine was my only bookers experience and it was delicious. Would buy if I ever saw it again.

Just bought my 3rd bottle of that one have 2 unopened. Might Fine is a really good bwtch

Though I’ve enjoyed all 3 batches I have opened, I will admit none have made me want to return for a second go at $90-$100… if only you could buy the bottle (sans box) for around $60 I’d be more of a regular I think.

I have that Charlie’s batch and man it’s delicious .Saw a guy post multiple bookers reviews and he had story teller batch edging out Charlie’s, but did say they’re very close and can go either way .

Awesome, thanks for the tip! 🥃

I loved pinkies but hadn’t had the other two. Just opened my storyteller and storyteller > pinkies

Good to know. I liked Pinkie’s but can’t say I go much above “like” for its price point.

Did you buy a bunch before trying? Sounds like your not a big Booker’s fan for having so many

I’ve bought them as I stumble across them and passed up opportunities to bunker more. Each time I open a new I keep thinking “this batch is going to be the one,” but none have surpassed the “7” mark for me (yet)… but maybe that’s gonna change tonight?

The Storyteller Batch in the middle. I’ve sipped through about half a bottle so far. It’s outstanding.

It’s nearing that time and your recommendation tied it up with Mighty Fine at 2-2-0… might have to make it a double crack. 🥃

My open are Mighty Fine > Kentucky Tea > Apprentice Batch

Thanks, appreciate it! Can I ask if there’s anything specific that puts Mighty Fine at the top? 🥃

More balanced to my palette vs. K.Tea. Familiar notes, proofy, but balanced. Seems to have a little more complexity than the K. Tea. Apprentice batch is harsh in comparison to both.

Thanks for the follow up detail!

All of them

Well since it’s Friday, I do plan on having 3+ drinks, so there isn’t flaw in your logic.

I like it, maybe a triple ‘blind’ tasting is in order.

Have you had any of those in question?

Only Charlie’s from those 6 batches, have a bottle of it. Also tried a sample of Ronnie’s and Tagalong, only three Bookers I’ve tried.

[did it](https://www.reddit.com/r/bourbon/s/1ZlMDcwPTZ)

Atta boy 👍

24-01 is the best. Do them in release order

As in “oldest release to newest to work toward the best” or latest to oldest?

Oldest to newest

Didn’t quite follow your suggestion but: [link](https://www.reddit.com/r/bourbon/s/1ZlMDcwPTZ)

Great write up! Cant argue with those results.

Thanks 🥃

We just got a case of the Springfield in my store. I’d like to hear how you like it.

👍🏼 After some wisdom and peer pressure from others, think I may end up semi-blinding all 3. Will post the results.

Niiiice! I Look forward to the book report.

[ended up doing this last night](https://www.reddit.com/r/bourbon/s/1ZlMDcwPTZ)

I have mighty fine and Springfield. Had 2 opportunities to get story teller for 100 and stupidly passed both times. Don't you dare say storyteller is the best!

😂well, I decided I’m gonna open all three and semi-blind them tonight… Will post results separately in this sub. Can’t make any promises. 🥃

[ooofffff, turns out…](https://www.reddit.com/r/bourbon/s/1ZlMDcwPTZ)