T O P

  • By -

RageInMyName

Didn't realise this sub was mostly American but here in the UK it's normal to say "I'm on like 10k a year "


aaarry

Yeah I know, it’s a reasonably fair assumption to make that a sub called “English learning” would actually have English people in it


Roth_Pond

🤨 america big


LotusGrowsFromMud

U.S.: neither of those would sound natural here.


Same-Technician9125

How would people say it in America?


Arumidden

Just say you “make 10K a year.” That’s really the most natural way to say it.


aaarry

The second one is fine though?


CigaleTranquille

The first two, I initially interpreted to mean he was trying to say something about running 10k's. 


LotusGrowsFromMud

No, not the first one or the second one. Both are awkward


aaarry

The second one is fine? Is this some weird American thing?


lilapense

Where are you from that "I am on like 10K a year" sounds normal?


aaarry

Shockingly, I’m from the place the language was shat into existence from, England, which also happens to use the variety of the language which is still most widely taught worldwide


CigaleTranquille

Is it a lower register thing there? With my limited knowledge of lower register BrE, I can kind of hear it.  Btw, a lot of "weird American things" are just older British things. 


aaarry

Kind of, it’s somewhere in the middle, I actually think “I’m on 20k” is what I’d say the most often talking about this. Also forgive me for getting wound up about this, I just don’t like being told I’m objectively wrong by closed minded Americans who think they speak the only correct form of the language.


CigaleTranquille

I gotcha. Thank you for explaining! I totally hear ya. My fellow americans do be saying foolish things sometimes ![gif](emote|free_emotes_pack|facepalm)


aaarry

That’s alright, you really do find differences in the most random of places between our two varieties of English. And same with my fellow countrymen (not least myself).


jdith123

It doesn’t sound natural, but people say things oddly all the time… I can imagine someone saying this about a salary scale: _for every year experience, you get moved up a column. I’m on 10k a year_. Or as shorthand for _I’m [living] on 10k a year._ which might be used for some kind of passive income or retirement income as opposed to earning/making money with a job.


GlobalIncident

In my experience "I'm \[living\] on 10k a year" doesn't necessarily mean passive income.


jdith123

Agreed, but it kind of emphasizes your total expenses rather than how much you are bringing in.


Whyistheplatypus

"I am on" means "I make" or rather, "my salary is" in this context. The addition of "like" also means "roughly". So if you made say, $11,500 per annum, you could say you "are on like 10k a year"


0bi_Wan_Jabroni

Maybe it’s a European thing, but no one says “I am on” to mean “I make” in the US.


Roth_Pond

Yeah they do


snukb

What region/dialect? I'm from the east coast and I've never heard this.


0bi_Wan_Jabroni

Nope.


Roth_Pond

Ok guess I'll go re-learn my native language then 🙄


0bi_Wan_Jabroni

Yeah you may want to because that is not a normal saying in the US. People will know what you mean but they’ll think you’re taking in a round about way.


InfinitePen5462

I’ve heard multiple US content creators and whatnot say “He’s on like” “I’m on like” to mean making money


0bi_Wan_Jabroni

It isn’t common


Whyistheplatypus

People speak English outside of the USA.


0bi_Wan_Jabroni

Wow, almost like that’s what I said in the first words of my sentence!


Whyistheplatypus

I just thought I'd remind you since you saw the need to comment that it wasn't an idiom in the USA. Despite nothing in my comment indicating I am American. I'm also not European. Because the anglosphere covers a third of the world.


AccomplishedAd7992

he never stated anything about you being american, i’m pretty sure he’s just referring to himself and saying “as an american” no one says that


Same-Technician9125

Are you Australian? Because I heard an Aussie said “I am like on….” in a clip.


Whyistheplatypus

Close! Kiwi


plasmaticmink25

I also think it works and I'm also a kiwi


0bi_Wan_Jabroni

I never said you were an American. You sure you know English?


Ultra_3142

UK perspective: I'd either say 'I earn about 10k per year' or more formally 'My salary is about 10k per year'. (£10k per year would be extremely low for context but just used the same number as the original question.)


tribalbaboon

The first one doesn't work, the second one is very natural


aaarry

The second one sounds alright, the first one is just incorrect


Aggravating-Method24

In most of the UK, second one is common. I had no idea Americans would find it so unnatural 


DryTart978

The latter most one is very natural to me